Case Summary: Damodar S. Prabhu v. Sayed Babalal H
By Priya Pillai

In short
A three-judge Supreme Court bench (3 May 2010) allowed the compounding of a Section 138 cheque-dishonour offence, set aside the appellant's conviction, and framed guidelines to push parties to compound early: no cost at the first or second hearing, then 10%, 15% and 20% of the cheque amount at later stages. Courts may reduce these costs for recorded reasons. In 2025, Sanjabij Tari v. Kishore S. Borcar modified the scale to nil, 5%, 7.5% and 10%.
In this brief
Background
Damodar S. Prabhu v. Sayed Babalal H, (2010) 5 SCC 663, arose from disputes in commercial transactions over five dishonoured cheques issued by the appellant, Damodar S. Prabhu. He had been convicted under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (NI Act), and the High Court of Bombay at Goa had ruled against him. By the time the matter reached the Supreme Court, the parties had settled and asked for the offence to be compounded under Section 147.
The Court said it was not necessary to go into the facts. It allowed the compounding, set aside the conviction, and used the case to address a larger problem: more than 38 lakh cheque-bouncing cases were pending as of October 2008, according to the 213th Law Commission Report, and parties often compounded only at a very late stage.
Case at a glance
| Citation | (2010) 5 SCC 663; AIR 2010 SC 1907 |
| Court and date | Supreme Court of India, 3 May 2010 |
| Bench | K.G. Balakrishnan CJI, P. Sathasivam and J.M. Panchal JJ. |
| Provisions | Sections 138 and 147, NI Act; Section 320, CrPC |
| Result | Compounding allowed, conviction set aside, guidelines framed |
| Current position | Cost scale modified by Sanjabij Tari (2025) |
| Full text | Read the order on Indian Kanoon |
Statutory Framework
Section 138, NI Act (inserted in 1988) punishes the drawer of a cheque dishonoured for insufficient funds with imprisonment up to two years, a fine up to twice the cheque amount, or both. The Court called it a "regulatory offence" and said its compensatory aspect should be given priority over the punitive aspect.
Section 147, NI Act (inserted in 2002) says that, notwithstanding the CrPC, every offence under the Act is compoundable. Section 320(9), CrPC says no offence shall be compounded except as provided by that section. Because Section 147 is a non-obstante provision in a special law, it overrides Section 320(9). But it gives no guidance on when compounding should happen.
Issues Before the Court
- How does Section 147 NI Act relate to Section 320 CrPC?
- What should be done about parties who compound only at a very late stage?
- How can multiple complaints on the same transaction be controlled?
Judgment: 3 May 2010
On the suggestion of the Attorney General, who appeared as amicus curiae, the Court directed that the following be followed:
- Summons: the writ of summons should tell the accused that compounding may be sought at the first or second hearing without costs.
- Graded costs: later compounding carries costs, set out in the table below. A competent court may reduce them, recording reasons in writing.
- Multiple complaints: the complainant must disclose on sworn affidavit that no other complaint has been filed in any other court on the same transaction. This direction was prospective.
The Court acknowledged that this could be seen as judicial law-making, but said that a "legislative vacuum" justified it.
Graded Cost Scheme at a Glance
| Stage of compounding (2010) | Cost (% of cheque amount) | Deposited with |
|---|---|---|
| First or second hearing | Nil | Not applicable |
| Later stage before the Magistrate | 10% | District Legal Services Authority |
| Sessions Court (revision or appeal) | 15% | District Legal Services Authority |
| High Court (revision or appeal) | 15% | State Legal Services Authority |
| Supreme Court | 20% | National Legal Services Authority |
Subsequent Developments
In Sanjabij Tari v. Kishore S. Borcar, 2025 INSC 1158, decided on 25 September 2025, the Supreme Court modified these guidelines. The new scale turns on when the accused pays the cheque amount:
| When the cheque amount is paid (2025) | Cost (% of cheque amount) |
|---|---|
| Before the accused's evidence is recorded | Nil |
| After that evidence, before the trial court's judgment | 5% |
| Before the Sessions Court or High Court in revision or appeal | 7.5% |
| Before the Supreme Court | 10% |
Read Sanjabij Tari on Indian Kanoon.
BNSS 2023 update: from 1 July 2024, CrPC §320 corresponds to BNSS §359. Sections 138 and 147 of the NI Act are unchanged.
The cheque-bounce compounding guide calculates the revised costs on a ₹2,00,000 cheque and explains what the court needs if the parties settle during an appeal.
Exam summary
Issue: How and when should Section 138 offences be compounded under Section 147 NI Act?
Held: Compounding allowed and conviction set aside. Section 147 overrides Section 320(9) CrPC. Guidelines framed to encourage compounding at an early stage.
Ratio: With a cheque-dishonour offence, the compensatory aspect takes priority over the punitive aspect, and graded costs can be used to discourage delay.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Damodar Prabhu was the accused, not the complainant. He issued the cheques and his conviction was set aside.
- It was a three-judge bench.
- Do not quote 10%, 15% and 20% as current. Sanjabij Tari (2025) modified them.
- All costs do not go to one authority. The authority depends on the court.
Significance
- Reducing arrears: the guidelines give parties a financial reason to settle early rather than litigate through several courts.
- Clarifying Section 147: the order confirms that the NI Act's own compounding provision prevails over the general bar in the CrPC.
- Controlling multiple complaints: the affidavit requirement addresses complaints filed in several places on one transaction.

About the author
Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.
