LegalFly

Doctrine of Repugnancy Under Article 254

In this article
  1. Apply Article 254 to the specific conflict
  2. Test what happens when both laws apply to the same operator
  3. Two laws assign Rani’s dispute to different tribunals
  4. Omar can comply with both record-keeping laws
  5. Why two laws may coexist in one case and collide in another
  6. Legislative competence and repugnancy
  7. State which obligation survives and where
  8. Sources
p>Article 254 resolves conflicts between a State law and a parliamentary or applicable existing law on a Concurrent List matter. The State law ordinarily yields to the extent of the conflict. A State law reserved for and given Presidential assent can prevail locally over an earlier law on the same matter. Parliament can legislate on that matter again.

Apply Article 254 to the specific conflict

  1. Identify the legislative field. Use Article 246 and the Seventh Schedule to classify the measures. Ask whether the provisions at issue are laws in the Concurrent field. A claim that one legislature had no power over the law's real subject raises a prior question of legislative competence.
  2. Read the provisions together. Try to give both laws effect. Conflict can arise if obeying one means disobeying the other, if Parliament intended an exhaustive regime, or if the laws in substance regulate the same subject matter in competing ways. That third inquiry can arise even without a direct contradiction or proof that Parliament intended to occupy the whole field. Sharing a broad topic alone is insufficient.
  3. Check the dates and the assent. Under Article 254(2), if the State law conflicts with an earlier parliamentary law or existing law on the matter, check whether the State law was reserved for the President's consideration and received assent directed to the particular conflict. Check whether the earlier law and the reason for the proposed State departure were put before the President. If the exception applies, the State law prevails within that State to the extent of the conflict.
  4. Check what Parliament did later. The proviso to Article 254(2) allows Parliament to legislate on the same matter again, including by adding to, amending, varying or repealing the State law. Identify the provisions affected before stating what survives.

Test what happens when both laws apply to the same operator

Two laws assign Rani’s dispute to different tribunals

Assume both legislatures can regulate a particular class of industrial disputes in the Concurrent field. A parliamentary law requires disputes of Rani's type to go to a named tribunal and bars every other body from deciding them. A State law directs the same disputes exclusively to a State board and bars the named tribunal from hearing them. If the State law has no applicable Presidential assent, the conflicting State provisions yield under Article 254(1). If the State law came later and satisfied Article 254(2), the State board rule could instead prevail there until Parliament legislated to displace it.

Omar can comply with both record-keeping laws

Assume Parliament requires Omar's business to retain specified employment records for at least two years and expressly leaves room for additional State requirements. A State law on the same Concurrent subject requires three years of retention. Omar can comply with both by keeping the records for three years. The text also shows that Parliament allowed supplementation. On these facts, there is no repugnancy merely because the two minimums differ.

Why two laws may coexist in one case and collide in another

M. Karunanidhi v. Union of India, (1979) 3 SCC 431, examined State and central criminal provisions. The Supreme Court treated the State offence as distinct and found that the provisions could coexist. It also noted the State Act’s amended Section 29, which expressly preserved the operation of other laws.

Forum for People's Collective Efforts v. State of West Bengal, (2021) 8 SCC 599, held West Bengal's real-estate statute repugnant to the central Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act. The Court considered how the State created a parallel regulatory regime in the same field, identified substantive differences and recorded that the State law had received no Presidential assent.

Legislative competence and repugnancy

DoctrineQuestion it answers
Pith and substanceWhat is the true subject of the law, and does the enacting legislature have power over it?
RepugnancyCan the competing provisions in the Concurrent field operate together? If they conflict, which prevails under Article 254?

Canada's federal paramountcy doctrine also looks for an operational conflict or frustration of a federal purpose. The Supreme Court of Canada explained those tests in Canadian Western Bank v. Alberta. India's text expressly makes provision for a State law with Presidential assent.

State which obligation survives and where

Identify the relevant Concurrent List field and quote or paraphrase the competing operative provisions. Explain whether simultaneous compliance is possible, whether Parliament intended to cover the field and whether two competing regimes occupy the same subject matter. Then address the sequence, reservation and assent, and any later parliamentary law. Finish by identifying the provisions that yield and the territory in which your answer applies.

Sources

Priya Pillai

About the author

Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.

More from PriyaLegalFly on YouTube