Doctrine of Severability Under Article 13
By Priya Pillai
In this article
- Could the remaining law stand on its own?
- Two ways a law can depend on the invalid part
- Neha challenges a ban on criticism
- Yusuf challenges the only route to a licence
- The test and one example from online speech
- Severability and reading down address different problems
- Describe the law that would be left
- Sources
Could the remaining law stand on its own?
In R.M.D. Chamarbaugwalla, the Supreme Court set out the considerations that govern severability. Apply them to the operation of the law as a whole.
- Locate the constitutional defect. Identify the words or applications that create the violation. Article 13(1) deals with laws in force before the Constitution. Article 13(2) bars the State from making a law that takes away or abridges Part III rights and makes a law void to the extent of that contravention.
- Test the remainder. Work out what the surviving text would do. A court can separate valid from invalid parts even within a single section where they are separable in substance. If the provisions form one inseparable scheme, the invalid part can bring down the rest of that scheme.
- Ask what the legislature intended. Would it have enacted the remaining law by itself? Read the design, object and history of the enactment. A remainder that operates on paper can still fail if removing the offending part produces a materially different law. A severability clause is an indication of intent, but it cannot make a scheme workable.
Two ways a law can depend on the invalid part
Neha challenges a ban on criticism
Assume a park Act sets opening hours and also includes a separate clause barring visitors from criticising local officials. Neha successfully challenges the speech clause. The opening hours still work without it and serve an independent management purpose. On those facts, the court could set aside the ban and leave the hours in place if it concludes the legislature meant the hours to operate independently.
Yusuf challenges the only route to a licence
A different Act creates a licensing scheme whose sole eligibility rule is an unconstitutional exclusion. Assume the Act gives the authority no workable criteria once that rule is removed, and the record shows that the legislature built the scheme around that rule. A court could not save the scheme simply by deleting the exclusion. It would have to supply a new eligibility policy, a job for the legislature.
The test and one example from online speech
R.M.D. Chamarbaugwalla v. Union of India, AIR 1957 SC 628, concerned the Prize Competitions Act, 1955. The Court construed the Act as directed at gambling competitions. It also considered severability on the assumption that the language covered competitions involving substantial skill. The gambling competitions could be dealt with separately because regulation of those competitions was the legislative object.
Shreya Singhal v. Union of India, (2015) 5 SCC 1, struck down Section 66A of the Information Technology Act in full. It found the provision violated Article 19(1)(a) and could not be saved under Article 19(2). The Court declined to preserve a narrower part of Section 66A. It separately upheld Section 69A and the associated blocking rules. See the guide to reasonable restrictions on speech.
Severability and reading down address different problems
| Method | What the court asks |
|---|---|
| Severability | Can the invalid part be separated while the valid part continues independently? |
| Reading down | Can the text bear a narrower construction that avoids the legal defect? |
The same judgment upheld Section 79 subject to a narrower reading of Section 79(3)(b) concerning when intermediaries had to act on actual knowledge. That was an example of reading down.
In the UK, for comparison, a declaration of incompatibility under Section 4 of the Human Rights Act 1998 does not affect the validity or continuing enforcement of the provision it concerns. This is a different remedial mechanism from invalidation under Article 13.
Describe the law that would be left
State the constitutional defect and identify the part you would remove. Apply the Chamarbaugwalla test to the actual remainder. Explain how it would operate, whether the legislature would have enacted it, and whether saving it would require making new law. Your conclusion should say how much of the scheme survives and why.
Sources
- Constitution of India, Article 13.
- R.M.D. Chamarbaugwalla v. Union of India, AIR 1957 SC 628.
- Shreya Singhal v. Union of India, (2015) 5 SCC 1, including the dispositions of Sections 66A, 69A and 79(3)(b).
- Human Rights Act 1998 (UK), Section 4.

About the author
Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.
