LegalFly

Preparation vs Attempt Under Section 62 BNS

In this article
  1. Start with the offence the person meant to commit
  2. The line between drafting an application and sending it
  3. Anil leaves the application at home
  4. Rekha submits the application and the institution detects the lie
  5. How the courts identify a direct step
  6. Intention, preparation, attempt and completion
  7. Explain which act changed the legal position
  8. Sources
p>Preparation is arranging the means to commit an offence. A criminal attempt goes further. The accused must act towards committing the offence with the necessary intent. Section 62 BNS applies to attempts to commit or cause certain offences under the Sanhita where it provides no specific punishment for the attempt.

Start with the offence the person meant to commit

  1. Identify the completed offence and its mental element. Specify what would have had to happen for the target offence to be complete. Identify the evidence of intent to commit it.
  2. Find an act towards commission. Ask whether the accused started carrying out the offence after making preparations. In Abhayanand Mishra, the Court explained that the law does not require the last possible act before completion.
  3. Explain why the act is close enough. The question is how the act relates to the intended offence in the full circumstances. In Mohd. Yakub, the opinions examined proximity and whether the acts, read together, showed the intended offence was being carried out.
  4. Check for a specific statutory provision. Section 62, the successor to former Section 511 IPC, applies to attempts to commit or cause an offence under the BNS punishable with life or other imprisonment, where the Sanhita provides no express punishment for the attempt. Preparation ordinarily falls outside this general attempt provision, though the BNS expressly punishes preparation in specified cases, such as preparation to commit dacoity under Section 310(4).

Section 62 caps imprisonment at half the applicable longest term or half of life imprisonment, as the case may be, and permits the fine provided for the offence or both forms of punishment. Section 6 counts life imprisonment as twenty years for calculating fractions unless another provision applies.

The line between drafting an application and sending it

Anil leaves the application at home

Anil intends to obtain an examination admission card by dishonestly claiming a qualification. He drafts his application, but never sends it or approaches the institution. Assume the allegation concerns Section 62 read with Section 318(4) BNS, which addresses cheating that dishonestly induces delivery of property. The intended deception has not been put into operation. On those facts, assembling the application is preparation for that offence. Any separate offence would require its own analysis.

Rekha submits the application and the institution detects the lie

Rekha similarly intends to obtain a card by deception. She sends the institution a knowingly false application and completes the requested application steps. Assume the institution detects the deception before delivering any admission card to anyone. The deception has been put to the intended recipient as a means to obtain the card. That act supports an attempt even though the completed delivery never occurs.

How the courts identify a direct step

In Abhayanand Mishra v. State of Bihar, AIR 1961 SC 1698, the Supreme Court upheld a conviction for attempting to cheat a university into delivering an admission card. It treated preparation of the application as an earlier stage and dispatch of the false application as an act towards the offence. The case applied former Section 420 read with Section 511 IPC.

In State of Maharashtra v. Mohd. Yakub, (1980) 3 SCC 57, the Court considered steps taken towards unlawful export under the customs law. The opinions treated proximity as the connection between the defendant's acts and the intended offence. The decision illustrates why an offence can reach the attempt stage before the planned result is achieved.

Intention, preparation, attempt and completion

StageWhat the facts show
IntentionThe intended offence, without execution.
PreparationArranging the means or setting up the plan.
AttemptAn act sufficiently connected to carrying out the intended offence.
CompletionThe elements of the substantive offence are all satisfied.

In England and Wales, Section 1 of the Criminal Attempts Act 1981 uses a statutory test of an act that is more than merely preparatory. For an Indian case, identify the governing BNS provision and apply the Indian cases on an act towards commission.

Explain which act changed the legal position

State the intended offence, the mental element, the alleged act towards commission and the elements still missing. Explain why the alleged act advances execution or remains preliminary. Check the charging provision and whether an attempt provision specific to that offence applies. The BNS overview gives the code context. If this concerns a charge you face, a local criminal lawyer can assess the exact allegations and procedural deadlines. This guide provides general legal information.

Sources

Priya Pillai

About the author

Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.

More from PriyaLegalFly on YouTube