LegalFly

Section 35 BNSS Notice and the Limits on Arrest

In this article
  1. When can police arrest without a warrant?
  2. What happens after a Section 35(3) notice?
  3. Two theft investigations, two outcomes
  4. Meera appears as directed
  5. Evidence of threats emerges after a missed appearance
  6. From CrPC Section 41A to BNSS Section 35
  7. How to structure an exam answer
  8. Arrest necessity in England and Wales
  9. If you receive a notice to appear
  10. Sources

A Section 35(3) BNSS notice directs a person suspected of a cognizable offence to appear when arrest is unnecessary. For cognizable offences punishable by up to seven years in prison, the Supreme Court treats notice as the rule and arrest as the exception. Police must identify a statutory ground and record why custody is necessary.

When can police arrest without a warrant?

Section 35 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 covers several grounds for arrest without a warrant. For the common situation in Section 35(1)(b), start with a reasonable complaint, credible information or reasonable suspicion about a cognizable offence punishable by up to seven years, with or without a fine. Then apply these steps.

  1. Check the basis for believing the person committed the offence. Section 35(1)(b)(i) requires reason to believe based on the complaint, information or suspicion.
  2. Identify why custody is needed. Under Section 35(1)(b)(ii), arrest must be necessary to prevent a further offence by that person, properly investigate the offence, prevent the person from destroying or tampering with evidence, stop them from using inducements, threats or promises to deter someone with knowledge of the facts from speaking to police or a court, or secure a court appearance that cannot otherwise be ensured.
  3. Check the written reasons. Under this clause, the officer must record reasons for arrest or for deciding against it. Where there is a reasonable complaint, credible information or reasonable suspicion that the person committed a cognizable offence and arrest is unnecessary under Section 35(1), Section 35(3) requires a notice directing the person to appear before the officer or at another place specified in the notice.

Identify the applicable clause before applying the checklist. Section 35(1)(c), for example, covers a cognizable offence punishable by more than seven years in prison or by death, where the officer has credible information and reason to believe, based on that information, that the person committed it. Section 35(7) requires prior permission from an officer of at least Deputy Superintendent of Police rank for arrest when the offence is punishable by imprisonment for less than three years and the person is infirm or over 60.

What happens after a Section 35(3) notice?

What happensWhat the BNSS requires
The person complies and continues to comply.Section 35(5) protects the person from arrest for the offence in the notice unless the officer records in writing the specific reasons why arrest is necessary.
The person fails to comply or is unwilling to identify themselves.Section 35(6) permits arrest for the offence in the notice, subject to any orders of a competent court. For an offence punishable by up to seven years, police still have to establish objective necessity under Section 35(1)(b).
Police rely on new information after issuing a notice.Under the January 2026 Satender Kumar Antil ruling, a subsequent arrest under Section 35(6) must rest on material or factors unavailable when the notice was issued. For offences punishable by up to seven years in prison, the officer must be satisfied the investigation cannot proceed effectively without custody.

The Supreme Court's July 2025 order in Satender Kumar Antil also held that WhatsApp and other electronic communications cannot substitute for prescribed service of a Section 35 notice. That ruling concerns service of the police notice. A real message can still be a reason to verify promptly what the police have issued.

Two theft investigations, two outcomes

Meera appears as directed

Police investigating a cognizable theft punishable by up to seven years have reason to believe Meera was involved. They send a properly served notice, and she appears when required. The investigator wants to arrest her to ask the same questions at the station on a second day. On those facts, the reason-to-believe requirement may be satisfied, but the officer has identified no investigative need for custody. Section 35(5) protects Meera while she continues to comply, subject to the recorded-reasons exception.

Evidence of threats emerges after a missed appearance

Police have independent evidence giving them reason to believe Kabir committed a cognizable theft punishable by up to seven years in prison. Kabir misses a properly served appearance date. A witness then produces new messages from Kabir threatening her if she speaks to police. The missed appointment alone leaves the necessity question open. The newly available threats give the officer a concrete statutory ground to examine. If custody is objectively necessary to prevent interference, the officer records the reasons in writing, and no competent court order bars arrest, Section 35(6) read with Section 35(1)(b) may permit it.

From CrPC Section 41A to BNSS Section 35

Section 35(1)(b) covers the arrest test formerly in CrPC Section 41(1)(b). BNSS Sections 35(3) to (6) cover notice and compliance, formerly addressed by CrPC Section 41A. Section 531 preserves the former Code for specified proceedings and investigations pending immediately before the BNSS commenced.

How to structure an exam answer

  1. Issue. Identify the offence, its maximum punishment and whether notice has already been served.
  2. Rule. For Section 35(1)(b), state the reason-to-believe and necessity requirements. If notice was served, identify whether Section 35(5) or 35(6) applies.
  3. Application. Match facts to a statutory ground. For a proposed arrest under Section 35(6), identify what became available after notice and explain why it matters.
  4. Conclusion. State whether arrest is justified on these facts and identify the written record the officer must make.

Arrest necessity in England and Wales

PACE Code G also directs police to justify arrest by reference to specific necessity grounds. It treats voluntary attendance as a possible alternative to arrest. In India, Section 35(4) imposes a duty to comply with a notice served under Section 35(3).

If you receive a notice to appear

Keep the notice, note the date and place, and promptly verify any unclear details with the issuing police station. An Indian criminal lawyer can help check service, advise if you cannot attend at the stated time and explain how the privilege against self-incrimination applies during questioning. This guide provides general legal information.

Sources

Priya Pillai

About the author

Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.

More from PriyaLegalFly on YouTube