LegalFly

Coercion vs Undue Influence Under the Indian Contract Act

In this article
  1. What Sections 15 and 16 require
  2. Different facts, different remedies
  3. A detained machine and a one-sided contract
  4. Harish refuses to release Tara's equipment
  5. Indira signs a transfer proposed by her adviser
  6. Asha negotiates a high price with another business
  7. Prove the relationship before drawing an inference
  8. Match the evidence to the kind of pressure
  9. Sources
p>Coercion under Section 15 of the Indian Contract Act involves using a forbidden act, unlawful detention of property or a threat of either to procure an agreement. Undue influence under Section 16 involves using a position of dominance to obtain an unfair advantage. Either can make the contract voidable if it caused the affected party’s consent.

What Sections 15 and 16 require

  1. For coercion, identify the act and its purpose. Section 15 covers committing or threatening an act forbidden by the penal law referred to in the section, or unlawfully detaining or threatening to detain property. The conduct must be to the prejudice of any person and intended to cause any person to enter an agreement.
  2. For undue influence, establish the position of dominance. Section 16(2) includes real or apparent authority, a fiduciary relationship, or a contract with a person whose mental capacity is affected by age, illness or mental or bodily distress. Then ask whether the stronger party actually used that position to obtain an unfair advantage.
  3. Check whether the burden shifts. Under Section 16(3), if a party in a position to dominate the other's will enters a transaction that appears unconscionable, that party must prove the contract was not induced by undue influence. An expensive bargain alone supplies no proof of the required position.

The wording of Section 15 still refers to the former IPC. For a present-day claim under that branch, check whether the relevant prohibition has been re-enacted in the BNS. Section 8 of the General Clauses Act applies to references to provisions that are repealed and re-enacted, unless a different intention appears. Section 358 BNS also preserves specified effects of the former IPC. The separate property-detention branch does not depend on identifying a penal offence.

Different facts, different remedies

QuestionCoercionUndue influence
Where does the pressure come from?Committing or threatening an act forbidden by the penal law referred to in Section 15, or unlawfully detaining or threatening to detain property.A person uses a position that lets them dominate the other's will.
What must the facts show?The conduct was intended to procure agreement and caused the consent in question.Use of the position to obtain an unfair advantage. A dominant position and apparent unconscionability trigger Section 16(3).
What can happen to the contract?Section 19 makes the agreement voidable at the option of the party whose consent was caused by coercion.Section 19A permits the court to set it aside absolutely or, where the affected party received a benefit under the contract, on terms the court considers just.

A detained machine and a one-sided contract

Harish refuses to release Tara's equipment

Harish holds Tara's machine after a fully paid repair. Assume he has no legal right to keep it. He demands that Tara sign an unrelated service contract before he will release it, and she signs to recover it. The unlawful detention, its purpose and Tara's reason for signing support coercion. Section 19 gives Tara the option to avoid the service agreement.

Indira signs a transfer proposed by her adviser

Indira relies on Ketan, her fiduciary financial adviser, to manage her investments. Ketan uses that position to persuade her to sell him an asset worth ₹10 lakh for ₹1 lakh. If the court finds he could dominate her will and the transaction appears unconscionable, Section 16(3) places the burden on him to show that undue influence did not induce the transfer. If the court sets it aside under Section 19A, the ₹1 lakh Indira received can bear on the terms of relief.

Asha negotiates a high price with another business

Asha's supplier quotes a steep price during a shortage, and Asha accepts after comparing alternatives. Assume no prohibited act or detention of property, and no authority, dependence or other facts showing dominance of her will. The high price by itself establishes neither claim.

Prove the relationship before drawing an inference

In Raghunath Prasad v. Sarju Prasad, AIR 1924 PC 60, the Privy Council explained the order of analysis under Section 16. Establish a position to dominate the will before using apparent unconscionability to shift the burden. In Subhas Chandra Das Mushib v. Ganga Prosad Das Mushib, AIR 1967 SC 878, the Supreme Court stressed the need for particulars and evidence. Kinship alone did not justify a presumption of undue influence.

English law separately recognises the doctrine of duress. The UK Supreme Court addressed the narrow scope of lawful-act economic duress in Pakistan International Airline Corp. v. Times Travel. For India, use the triggers in Sections 15 and 16 before drawing on any analogy.

Match the evidence to the kind of pressure

State how consent was obtained. Apply Section 15 to the specific act or demand, or apply Section 16 to the parties' relationship and the advantage obtained. Then ask whether Section 16(3) shifts the burden of proof and select Section 19 or 19A for relief. The meeting of the minds guide explains where free consent fits in contract formation. If this happened to you, preserve the agreement and messages and consult a local lawyer about remedies and deadlines. This guide provides general legal information.

Sources

Priya Pillai

About the author

Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.

More from PriyaLegalFly on YouTube