Common Intention vs Common Object Under the BNS
By Priya Pillai
In this article
- Identify the route to group liability
- What changes between Sections 3(5) and 190
- Two participants and six people at a boundary dispute
- Ira and Neel carry out a shared decision to damage a sign
- Meena merely stands near an unlawful assembly
- How courts infer intention and object
- Apply the rule to the person charged
- Sources
Identify the route to group liability
- For Section 3(5), identify the criminal act. Show what several people did and what criminal intention they shared. A shared intention can form at the scene, but it must precede the relevant criminal act. Separate personal intentions that happen to coincide are insufficient.
- Connect the accused to the joint act. Use the circumstances to show participation in a criminal act done in furtherance of that common intention. The participants can play different roles. Conduct that facilitates the act can count even without a separate overt act. Presence by itself does not establish the required sharing and participation.
- For Section 190, first establish an unlawful assembly. Section 189(1) requires at least five people and one of the listed common objects, such as committing criminal trespass or another offence. Establish the accused's membership at the time of the offence. Under Section 189(2), a person becomes a member when, aware of the facts making the assembly unlawful, they intentionally join or continue in it.
- Link the offence to that object. Section 190 applies if a member committed the offence in pursuit of the common object or if the members knew it was likely to be committed in pursuit of it. Membership at the relevant time matters. Proof that every member personally committed an overt act is unnecessary.
What changes between Sections 3(5) and 190
| Question | Common intention | Common object |
|---|---|---|
| Current and former provision | BNS Section 3(5), formerly IPC Section 34. | BNS Section 190 read with Section 189, formerly IPC Sections 149 and 141–142. |
| How many people? | More than one participant. No minimum of five applies. | An unlawful assembly requires five or more people. |
| What connects the accused to the offence? | Participation in a criminal act in furtherance of a shared intention. | Membership when the offence occurs and the required link to the assembly's common object. |
Two participants and six people at a boundary dispute
Ira and Neel carry out a shared decision to damage a sign
Ira and Neel agree to destroy a privately owned noticeboard. Ira holds the board steady while Neel breaks it. Assume the facts establish criminal mischief and that both intended the damage. Both roles further the shared intention, so Section 3(5) can apply. With only two people involved, Section 190's unlawful-assembly requirement fails.
Meena merely stands near an unlawful assembly
Six people knowingly and intentionally join a group whose shared object is to commit criminal trespass on a disputed site. One member commits that offence in pursuit of the object. On those facts, Section 190 can apply to those who were members at the time even if only one personally crosses the boundary. Meena happened to be waiting on the public street and did not join the group. Her proximity alone fails the membership requirement.
How courts infer intention and object
In Suresh v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (2001) 3 SCC 673, the Supreme Court examined the difference between sharing an intention and participation in the criminal act under former Section 34 IPC. The Court examined each accused’s role even though the final act could be attributed to one participant.
Lalji v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (1989) 1 SCC 437, explained that an assembly initially lawful can become unlawful and that a separate overt act by every member is unnecessary once the statutory conditions are met. Kuldip Yadav v. State of Bihar, (2011) 5 SCC 324, stressed that the court must find both the unlawful assembly's common object and the connection to the offence. These cases interpreted former Section 149 IPC.
In England and Wales, R v. Jogee addresses a separate doctrine of secondary liability. Foresight may be evidence of intention to assist or encourage, but the two are distinct. For an Indian assembly question, apply Section 190's express knowledge limb.
Apply the rule to the person charged
Start with the underlying offence. Identify the evidence of common intention and participation or the number, object and membership of the unlawful assembly. If you rely on Section 190, state which limb links the offence to the object. The BNS Chapter 1 guide explains where Section 3 fits in the Sanhita. If you are facing a charge, consult a local criminal lawyer about the allegations and applicable procedure. This guide provides general legal information.
Sources
- Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, Sections 3(5), 189 and 190.
- Suresh v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (2001) 3 SCC 673.
- Lalji v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (1989) 1 SCC 437.
- Kuldip Yadav v. State of Bihar, (2011) 5 SCC 324.
- R v. Jogee, [2016] UKSC 8, paragraphs 79–90.

About the author
Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.
