LegalFly

Delegated Legislation in India: Powers, Limits and Examples

In this article
  1. Start with the section that grants the power
  2. Two rules under the same Act
  3. Leela's water-testing rule
  4. Rafiq's licence renewal
  5. What the Supreme Court examines
  6. Write the challenge in the right order
  7. Sources
p>Statutory delegated legislation in India is law made under authority granted by an Act, typically in the form of rules, regulations or bye-laws. The legislature sets the policy and may authorise another body to fill in the details. A rule can be struck down if it exceeds the grant, conflicts with the Act or violates the Constitution.

Start with the section that grants the power

Suppose a licensing authority says that its latest notification has the force of law. Take the notification and its parent Act side by side. The label on the document tells you less than what the Act empowers the authority to do.

  1. Find the grant. Identify the section, the authorised rule-maker and the subjects on which that person or body can make rules.
  2. Test the grant itself. Read the statute as a whole for legislative policy and standards. The legislature can leave technical detail to the delegate, but it must perform its essential function of determining the policy.
  3. Test the rule. Compare the operative words of the rule with the power conferred, the scheme of the parent Act and other applicable law, including the Constitution. Look separately at any required steps such as prior publication. Where a Central Act or Regulation makes rule-making or bye-law-making subject to previous publication, Section 23 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 requires publication of a draft and notice of the date after which it will be considered. The rule-maker and any required approving authority must consider timely objections and suggestions.
GroundQuestion to ask
Excessive delegationDid the legislature confer a power so broad that it gave away an essential legislative function?
Rule exceeds the Act (ultra vires)Did the delegate make a rule outside the authority the Act actually grants?

Two rules under the same Act

Leela's water-testing rule

A fictional Act sets drinkable-water standards for bottlers and authorises the state government to prescribe the frequency and method of lab testing. Leela challenges a state rule requiring a sample from each production facility every quarter. The state is the named delegate, and quarterly sampling specifies how often to check a standard the legislature has already set. On those facts, her argument that the rule exceeds the subject of the grant fails. A failure to follow a required procedure would be a separate question.

Rafiq's licence renewal

Under the same Act, the department rejects Rafiq's renewal because a rule made under the testing power excludes companies with directors born outside the state. Even if the state made the rule correctly on paper, the grant covers testing methods and frequency. It supplies no authority to create a separate eligibility bar. Rafiq can challenge the rule against that grant before reaching any constitutional equality question.

What the Supreme Court examines

In re Delhi Laws Act, 1912, AIR 1951 SC 332, contains several opinions on legislative delegation. In that advisory reference, a majority found that Section 2 of the Part C States (Laws) Act, 1950 went beyond permissible delegation insofar as it allowed repeal or amendment of corresponding laws already in force, other than Central Acts. The decision is a starting point for the distinction between leaving details to another body and giving away essential legislative work.

State of Tamil Nadu v. P. Krishnamurthy, (2006) 4 SCC 517, identifies grounds for testing subordinate legislation. They include lack of legislative competence, breach of fundamental rights or another constitutional provision, failure to conform to or stay within the enabling Act, conflict with another enactment, and manifest arbitrariness or unreasonableness so serious that the legislature could not be taken to have authorised the rule. The Court also starts from a presumption of validity. Show the conflict with the law on the facts rather than simply calling a rule harsh.

Write the challenge in the right order

Frame the issue around the rule the government made. Quote the grant and identify the limit from Delhi Laws Act or Krishnamurthy. Match the rule’s effect and procedure to the grant. Conclude by locating any defect in the grant itself or in the rule. The distinction also helps when choosing grounds for a challenge to an order applying the rule.

For the separate question of a legislature's field of power, see the doctrine of pith and substance.

In the UK, Section 5 of the Statutory Instruments Act 1946 provides a parliamentary annulment procedure where the enabling Act makes an instrument subject to it. Indian statutes can impose their own procedures. For example, Section 26 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 requires rules made under that Act to be laid before both Houses of Parliament.

Sources

Priya Pillai

About the author

Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.

More from PriyaLegalFly on YouTube