Administrative Law
10 entries
Case Summary: Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission
584 U.S. 617 (2018)
Baker Jack Phillips refused to make a custom wedding cake for a same-sex couple on religious grounds, and the Colorado Civil Rights Commission found he had violated the state public-accommodations law. The Supreme Court reversed 7-2 (Kennedy J.), but narrowly: it held the Commission had shown unconstitutional hostility to Phillips's faith — a commissioner had likened his beliefs to defenses of slavery and the Holocaust, and the Commission had treated other bakers more leniently. The Court did not decide whether a business has a free-speech or free-exercise right to refuse such services; that question was later answered (for expressive products) in 303 Creative v. Elenis (2023).
Case Summary: Entick v Carrington (1765)
(1765) 19 St Tr 1029; 95 ER 807
The Court of Common Pleas held that a Secretary of State's warrant to search a house and seize a person's papers had no legal basis. Every invasion of private property is a trespass, and an officer who enters must justify it by law.
Reasonable Apprehension of Bias in Indian Administrative Law
A reasonable apprehension of bias depends on the circumstances a decision-maker brings to the case. The affected person's suspicion needs an objective basis.
Writ of Quo Warranto in India Under Article 226
Quo warranto tests a person's legal entitlement to occupy a substantive public office. The court looks for a binding requirement the appointment violated.
Internal Committee vs Local Committee Under the POSH Act
The POSH Act directs complaints to the workplace Internal Committee or, in specified cases, the district Local Committee. The identity of the respondent can change the route.
Writ of Mandamus in India Under Article 226
Mandamus can require an authority or body to perform a public duty owed to the applicant. The legal duty matters even where the respondent is privately managed.
Delegated Legislation in India: Powers, Limits and Examples
Delegated legislation lets an authority make binding rules under powers granted by an Act. The Act must set the policy, and the rule must stay within the authority the Act grants.
Principles of Natural Justice in Indian Administrative Law
A fair administrative decision ordinarily requires an impartial decision-maker and a meaningful opportunity to respond. The procedure depends on the statute and the decision's consequences.
Writ of Certiorari in India: When a Court Can Quash an Order
Certiorari lets a High Court quash a tribunal's or similar adjudicatory decision for a qualifying legal defect. It does not let the High Court rehear the facts as an appeal court.
Administrative Law in India: Definition, Sources & Examples
Administrative law governs how public authorities exercise power in India. It draws on the Constitution, delegated legislation, and judicial review to protect citizens from arbitrary state action.
