Medical Negligence in India: Duty, Breach and Causation
By Priya Pillai
In this article
- What a claimant has to establish
- How a missed review differs from a complication
- A missed result delays Farah's treatment
- Rohan develops a complication after appropriate treatment
- Why the standard of care and evidence both matter
- Civil and criminal negligence use different standards
- Describe the injury that proper care would have avoided
- Sources
What a claimant has to establish
- Duty. Identify the person or hospital that undertook the treatment and the care for which each was responsible. A doctor's assessment and a hospital's follow-up arrangements may raise different questions.
- Breach. Identify the act or omission and ask what a reasonably competent practitioner in the relevant field would have done in the circumstances. In Kusum Sharma, the Supreme Court explained that a genuine difference of medical opinion or the choice of one acceptable course of treatment does not establish negligence.
- Harm caused by the breach. Show how the departure caused the injury for which compensation is claimed. Establishing that the injury occurred after treatment still leaves the question of what caused it.
How a missed review differs from a complication
A missed result delays Farah's treatment
Farah's doctor undertakes her follow-up. The hospital receives an urgent test result, but the doctor fails to review it for three days. Assume the treatment records and an independent specialist establish that a reasonably competent practitioner would have acted on the first day and that the delay allowed an otherwise avoidable injury to develop. Those facts support duty, breach and causation. The claim turns on the harm attributable to the delay, even if the doctor did not cause Farah's underlying illness.
Rohan develops a complication after appropriate treatment
Rohan's surgeon discusses a known risk, selects an accepted operation and responds promptly when the risk materialises. Assume the records support reasonable care at each stage. The surgeon owed a duty and Rohan suffered an injury. Without a departure from reasonable care linked to that injury, the civil negligence claim fails on these facts.
Why the standard of care and evidence both matter
- Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, (2005) 6 SCC 1. The Court distinguished ordinary civil negligence from gross or very high-degree negligence in a prosecution under former Section 304A IPC.
- Kusum Sharma v. Batra Hospital and Medical Research Centre, (2010) 3 SCC 480. The Court assessed professional care against reasonable competence and allowed room for genuine differences in diagnosis and treatment.
- M.A. Biviji v. Sunita, 2023 INSC 938. The Court restated the claimant's need to establish a duty, breach and injury attributable to that breach.
- V. Kishan Rao v. Nikhil Super Speciality Hospital, (2010) 5 SCC 513. The Court rejected a blanket rule requiring expert evidence in every consumer case alleging medical negligence. The forum can consider whether the particular dispute requires it.
Civil and criminal negligence use different standards
| Question | Civil negligence | Criminal death by negligence |
|---|---|---|
| What must be shown? | A duty, breach and resulting harm, proved on the balance of probabilities. | The prosecution must prove the statutory offence beyond reasonable doubt. Jacob Mathew required gross or very high-degree negligence under former Section 304A IPC. |
| What law applies? | The law of negligence. The forum and remedy depend on the claim. | Section 106(1) BNS, in force from 1 July 2024, is the current provision for causing death by a rash or negligent act that does not amount to culpable homicide. Identify the law in force when the conduct occurred. |
Section 106(1) BNS expressly provides a maximum of two years' imprisonment and liability to a fine where a registered medical practitioner causes death by the specified act while performing a medical procedure. The section defines a registered medical practitioner by reference to a recognised medical qualification and entry in a national or state medical register. Jacob Mathew construed the former IPC provision. In 2026, the Rajasthan High Court applied its gross-negligence approach to a police case that included a Section 106(1) BNS allegation when it declined to quash the proceedings against the doctor at the preliminary stage. In the UK, McCulloch v. Forth Valley Health Board used the professional practice test to identify which treatment alternatives are reasonable for a consent discussion.
Describe the injury that proper care would have avoided
On an exam, state who owed the duty and identify the alleged error in a sentence. Apply the professional standard to that act and explain how the injury would likely have differed with reasonable care. If the question concerns criminal prosecution, deal with the statutory elements and the threshold for criminal negligence separately. The essential elements of tort guide places negligence alongside other bases for civil liability.
If this happened to you, request copies of the clinical records, consent forms and discharge papers. Keep a dated account of subsequent care and expenses. An Indian lawyer can assess the appropriate forum and filing deadline. This guide provides general legal information.
Sources
- Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, Sections 106(1) and 358, and commencement notification S.O. 850(E).
- Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, (2005) 6 SCC 1.
- Kusum Sharma v. Batra Hospital and Medical Research Centre, (2010) 3 SCC 480.
- M.A. Biviji v. Sunita, 2023 INSC 938, paragraphs 33–36.
- V. Kishan Rao v. Nikhil Super Speciality Hospital, (2010) 5 SCC 513.
- Dr. J.P. Gupta v. State of Rajasthan, 2026:RJ-JP:31018, paragraphs 10–14.
- McCulloch v. Forth Valley Health Board, [2023] UKSC 26.

About the author
Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.
