LegalFly

Offer vs Invitation to Offer Under Indian Contract Law

In this article
  1. Ask whose assent will close the bargain
  2. How the rule works in two bargains
  3. Farida asks about six desks
  4. Nikhil offers a reward for his camera
  5. What the courts looked for
  6. Find the point at which the agreement can form
  7. Track the exchange in order
  8. Sources
p>An offer is a proposal that the other person can accept as it stands. An invitation to offer asks that person to make a proposal, which the inviter can then accept or reject. Under Indian contract law, the wording and circumstances matter. A stated price alone does not establish that the speaker has made an offer.

Ask whose assent will close the bargain

  1. Identify the proposal. Section 2(a) of the Indian Contract Act requires a person to indicate willingness to do or abstain from doing something with a view to obtaining the other's assent. Read the whole communication, including any term reserving approval.
  2. Identify the acceptance. Under Sections 2(b) and 7, acceptance turns a proposal into a promise and must be absolute and unqualified. A reply that changes the proposed bargain does not accept the original terms.
  3. Check for acceptance by performance. Under Section 8, performing the conditions of a proposal can amount to acceptance. This matters where someone makes a definite reward offer to the public on stated conditions.

How the rule works in two bargains

Farida asks about six desks

Farida asks Dev what he charges for six desks. Dev replies, “₹3,000 per desk. Submit an order and I will confirm whether I can supply six by Friday.” Farida places the order. Dev's reply stated a price and expressly reserved confirmation. Farida's order can be a proposal, but she needs Dev's assent to it before there is a bargain on these facts.

Nikhil offers a reward for his camera

Nikhil posts that he will pay ₹4,000 to anyone who returns his camera, identified by serial number, to a named shop by Saturday. He reserves no further approval. Rema reads the notice and returns the camera as specified on Friday. The wording shows a definite commitment, and Rema performs the stated conditions with knowledge of the proposal. Section 8 can supply acceptance without a separate promise from Rema.

What the courts looked for

In Bank of India v. O.P. Swarnakar, (2003) 2 SCC 721, the Supreme Court treated the nationalised banks' voluntary retirement schemes as invitations to offer. The employees applied and the banks retained the power to accept or reject the applications. The wording of the particular scheme mattered.

Two English cases illustrate the range. In Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v. Boots Cash Chemists (Southern) Ltd., [1953] 1 QB 401, the goods on self-service shelves invited the customer to make an offer at the checkout. In Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co., [1893] 1 QB 256, the particular advertisement made an enforceable reward offer to people who performed its conditions. The court took the company's stated bank deposit as evidence of a serious promise. The Carlill case brief gives the facts.

Find the point at which the agreement can form

CommunicationLegal effectIllustration
OfferAssent on the proposed terms can form the promise.A definite reward on stated conditions.
Invitation to offerThe recipient can make a proposal. Further assent is needed.A quote expressly subject to approval.

Track the exchange in order

Identify the first communication that looks like a commitment. Apply Sections 2 and 7 to the words used and ask whether someone reserved the last say. If the alleged acceptance is an act, explain which proposed condition the person performed under Section 8. State whether the facts show an agreement and when it formed.

Sources

Priya Pillai

About the author

Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.

More from PriyaLegalFly on YouTube