LegalFly

Privity of Contract in India: Who Can Enforce a Promise?

In this article
  1. Read the agreement before tracing the money
  2. The same payment can accompany two different contracts
  3. Asha helps Ritu pay for repairs
  4. Asha buys a repair as a gift
  5. A named benefit and an enforceable charge
  6. Privity and consideration answer different questions
  7. Test the claimant's right to sue
  8. Sources
p>Privity of contract in India generally means that a person who is outside an agreement cannot enforce its promises merely because the agreement benefits them. Section 2(d) of the Indian Contract Act allows consideration to come from the promisee or another person. Who supplies consideration and who can sue are separate questions.

Read the agreement before tracing the money

  1. Find the parties. Identify who made the proposal and who accepted it. Section 2(c) calls them the promisor and the promisee.
  2. Find the consideration. Under Section 2(d), an act, abstinence or promise can be consideration when it is at the promisor's desire. The promisee or another person can supply it. See the guide to consideration for how that requirement works.
  3. Identify the basis for enforcement. A party can invoke their own contractual rights if the agreement is enforceable. A nonparty ordinarily needs a separate legal basis, such as a beneficiary's interest under a trust or a qualifying family arrangement. For a claim based on a charge, identify the property and the enforceable right the instrument gives the beneficiary.

The same payment can accompany two different contracts

Asha helps Ritu pay for repairs

A repair shop promises Ritu that it will fix her sewing machine for ₹2,000. At the shop's request, Ritu's sister Asha pays that sum as the price of the promised repairs. The shop then refuses to do the work. Ritu is the promisee and can rely on the repair agreement, assuming the ordinary conditions for enforcement are met. Asha's payment can be consideration under Section 2(d).

Asha buys a repair as a gift

Change the agreement. The shop now makes its promise to Asha alone, who buys the repair as a gift for Ritu. Assume there is no agency, trust, charge or other basis for Ritu to enforce it. The same machine and the same sum are involved. As the beneficiary of the gift, Ritu is still outside the contract. Asha has the contractual claim if the shop breaches.

A named benefit and an enforceable charge

In M.C. Chacko v. State Bank of Travancore, (1969) 2 SCC 343, the Supreme Court examined a family deed that directed one recipient to discharge a debt. The deed did not create a charge in the bank's favour. The bank could not enforce the undertaking in that deed simply because the payment would benefit it. The Court recognised exceptions for trust beneficiaries and qualifying family arrangements, and distinguished a marriage arrangement secured by a charge in the beneficiary's favour.

In Khwaja Muhammad Khan v. Husaini Begam, (1910) 37 IA 152 (PC), a marriage arrangement charged specified property with payment of an allowance to the bride. The Privy Council allowed her to enforce the claim despite her absence as a party to the agreement. The charge and her position as beneficiary mattered.

Privity and consideration answer different questions

QuestionWhat to look for
Who can sue on the promise?A contractual party or a person with an identified legal basis for enforcing the obligation.
Who can furnish the consideration?The promisee or another person under Section 2(d), if the act, abstinence or promise is at the promisor's desire.

In England and Wales, Section 1 of the Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999 gives a third party expressly identified in the contract by name, class or description a statutory route to enforce certain terms. This can apply where the contract expressly allows enforcement or the term purports to confer a benefit and the contract does not show a contrary intention. That is a separate statutory test.

Test the claimant's right to sue

Start with the claimant's relationship to the promise. State the rule from M.C. Chacko, then use Section 2(d) to deal separately with who provided consideration. If the claimant is outside the bargain, look for language creating a trust, a charge in the claimant’s favour or a qualifying family arrangement. Conclude by identifying whose claim the facts support.

Sources

Priya Pillai

About the author

Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.

More from PriyaLegalFly on YouTube