Consideration in Indian Contract Law
By Priya Pillai
In this article
- How to identify consideration under Section 2(d)
- The three exceptions in Section 25
- Consideration and privity of contract
- A third-party payment and an unsolicited repair
- A maker asks for payment from the buyer's father
- A shop benefits from a repair it never asked for
- Cases worth reading
- How to analyse an earlier act on an exam
- The English comparison
- Sources
Under Section 2(d) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, consideration can be an act, a promise or a decision to refrain from doing something at the promisor's request. It may come from the promisee or another person. Section 25 generally makes agreements without consideration void and sets out three exceptions.
How to identify consideration under Section 2(d)
- Start with the promise you are trying to enforce. Name the promisor and identify the act, forbearance or promise given in return.
- Ask whose request prompted it. The act or promise must be at the promisor's desire. The fact that it benefits the promisor is insufficient on its own.
- Identify who supplied it and when. The promisee or another person can provide it. Section 2(d) covers something already done at the promisor's desire, something done now or something promised for later.
- Check that it is lawful. Under Section 23, consideration can be unlawful, for example if it is forbidden by law or fraudulent. Section 25, Explanation 2, says that inadequacy alone does not make an agreement void if the promisor freely consented. A court may consider inadequacy when deciding whether the promisor's consent was free.
For a sale on credit, the seller's promise to deliver goods and the buyer's promise to pay later can each supply consideration for the other. Section 2(f) calls these reciprocal promises. For a separate requirement of formation, see meeting of the minds in contract law.
The three exceptions in Section 25
- Natural love and affection. The parties must stand in a near relation to each other, the promise must be based on natural love and affection, and the agreement must be expressed in writing and registered.
- Compensation for something already done. The promisor can promise to compensate someone, wholly or partly, for a completed act that the person voluntarily did for the promisor or that the promisor was legally bound to do.
- Payment of a time-barred debt. A promise to pay all or part of an otherwise enforceable debt barred by limitation can bind if it is in writing and signed by the person to be charged or their generally or specially authorised agent.
Section 25 also preserves the validity, as between donor and recipient, of gifts actually made. A transfer already carried out and an unperformed promise to give raise different questions.
Consideration and privity of contract
| Question | Where to look | Indian rule |
|---|---|---|
| Can someone else supply the consideration? | Who acted, refrained or promised at the promisor's desire? | Section 2(d) allows the promisee or any other person to supply it. |
| Can someone else sue on the promise? | To whom was the promise made and who is a party to the contract? | A person outside the contract generally cannot enforce it, subject to recognised exceptions. |
A third-party payment and an unsolicited repair
A maker asks for payment from the buyer's father
Tara promises Neel that she will make him a desk if his father pays ₹8,000. At Tara's request, Neel's father pays that sum. Neel accepts Tara's terms and is the person to whom she promises delivery.
The requested act is the payment. It came from Neel's father at Tara's desire, which Section 2(d) permits. Money paid for a desk is lawful consideration on these facts. Neel is Tara's promisee, so the fact that his father supplied the payment does not prevent Neel from enforcing the bargain.
A shop benefits from a repair it never asked for
Maya repairs a shared lane solely at the property manager's request while carrying out her maintenance contract. She does the work for the manager. Later, a shop owner who benefits from the work tells Maya he will pay her ₹5,000, but she gives him no fresh promise and he pays nothing.
The owner is the promisor for the ₹5,000. The repair was done at the manager's request, so it supplies no Section 2(d) consideration for the owner's promise. Maya also performed a duty to the manager, rather than volunteering work for the shop owner or taking care of one of his legal duties. The stated facts give her no basis for Section 25(2), and the other exceptions do not fit.
Cases worth reading
- Durga Prasad v. Baldeo, (1881) ILR 3 All 221. The Allahabad High Court found no consideration for the shopkeepers' promise to pay commission. The plaintiff had established the market at the Collector's request, rather than at the shopkeepers' desire.
- Venkata Chinnaya Rau v. Venkataramaya Garu, (1882) ILR 4 Mad 137. A daughter who received property under a gift deed made a separate promise to pay an annuity to her mother's brothers. The Madras High Court allowed them to recover. Kindersley J. relied on Section 2(d)'s broad definition of consideration and read the gift and the promise together.
- M.C. Chacko v. State Bank of Travancore, (1969) 2 SCC 343. The bank could not enforce a covenant in a family deed to which it was not a party. The Supreme Court distinguished Section 2(d)'s rule on who can provide consideration from the rule on who can enforce a contract.
How to analyse an earlier act on an exam
- Issue. Identify the promise and the act that supposedly supports it.
- Rule. Set out Section 2(d), including the promisor's desire. Identify any relevant subsection of Section 25.
- Application. Ask who wanted the work done at the time. If it was done without a request, look at whom it was voluntarily done for and whether it discharged the promisor's legal duty.
- Conclusion. State whether the promise has consideration or fits an exception, then address who may enforce it.
The English comparison
Tweddle v. Atkinson illustrates the English common-law requirement that consideration move from the promisee. In England and Wales, Section 1 of the Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999 separately allows a qualifying third party to enforce a term in specified circumstances. In an Indian problem, begin with Sections 2(d) and 25 and analyse privity separately.
Sources
- Indian Contract Act, 1872, Sections 2(d), 2(f), 10, 23 and 25.
- Durga Prasad v. Baldeo, (1881) ILR 3 All 221.
- Venkata Chinnaya Rau v. Venkataramaya Garu, (1882) ILR 4 Mad 137, judgment reproduced in the University of Delhi casebook.
- M.C. Chacko v. State Bank of Travancore, (1969) 2 SCC 343.
- Tweddle v. Atkinson (1861) 1 B & S 393, 121 ER 762.
- Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999, Section 1.

About the author
Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.
