Section 70 of the Indian Contract Act and Non-Gratuitous Benefits
By Priya Pillai
In this article
- The three conditions for compensation or restoration
- What the recipient chose to keep
- Farida's shelves go straight into the retailer's store
- Dev returns the unsolicited merchandise
- Why an invalid contract and an existing contract lead to different questions
- Section 70 compared with Section 65
- Prove the benefit before calculating an award
- Sources
The three conditions for compensation or restoration
- Lawful work or delivery for the recipient. Identify the service or thing and show that it was done for or delivered to the person from whom compensation is claimed. A benefit that reaches them incidentally does not by itself establish that element.
- Intent at the time of performance. The claimant must have intended to act on a non-gratuitous basis. A written estimate, payment discussion or ordinary commercial arrangement can help show that intent. A later demand for money cannot by itself turn a gift into paid work.
- Voluntary enjoyment of the benefit. Identify what the recipient accepted, retained or used and whether they had a choice. In B. K. Mondal, the Supreme Court explained that a person can refuse the work or return the thing. A claim based on voluntary use is stronger than one based only on an invoice.
If all three conditions are met, Section 70 requires compensation in respect of the work or thing, or its restoration. Where a subsisting contract already governs the work and the payment in dispute, start with that agreement and the rights it gives the parties.
What the recipient chose to keep
Farida's shelves go straight into the retailer's store
Farida lawfully makes and delivers shelving for Sumeet's store after his manager asks for it. Her messages say she expects payment. Assume the facts leave no enforceable contract for the work. Sumeet can refuse the shelves but instead installs them and uses them for several months. The delivery, payment expectation and voluntary use each support a Section 70 claim. Evidence of the value of the shelving and work will matter to the remedy.
Dev returns the unsolicited merchandise
A wholesaler sends Dev ten display stands with an invoice although he never requested them. Dev tells the supplier to collect them and promptly returns them unopened. Even if the supplier intended to be paid and the delivery was lawful, Dev did not enjoy the benefit. The invoice alone supplies no Section 70 liability on these facts.
Why an invalid contract and an existing contract lead to different questions
In State of West Bengal v. B. K. Mondal & Sons, AIR 1962 SC 779, government officers requested construction without binding the government. The government used the completed structures. The Supreme Court upheld compensation under Section 70, with West Bengal succeeding to the liability.
In Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd. v. Tata Communications Ltd., (2019) 5 SCC 341, the Court rejected a Section 70 claim where the matter was governed by the parties' contract. It distinguished a statutory obligation arising from use of a benefit from payment rights set by an existing agreement.
Section 70 compared with Section 65
| Provision | Starting point | What can be owed? |
|---|---|---|
| Section 70 | Lawful non-gratuitous work or delivery and the recipient's voluntary enjoyment of it. | Compensation or restoration. |
| Section 65 | An advantage received under an agreement discovered to be void or a contract that becomes void. | Restoration of the advantage or compensation for it. |
For comparison, the UK Supreme Court in Benedetti v. Sawiris considered objective market value as the starting point for valuing services in an English unjust enrichment claim. An Indian claim under Section 70 starts with the statute's own conditions.
Prove the benefit before calculating an award
In an exam, identify the work, who it was for and the evidence of an intention to charge. Set out how the recipient chose to take the benefit. Then explain whether a valid contract governs the payment and identify the statutory remedy. The consideration guide explains the different role of a bargained-for exchange in forming a contract.
If you are seeking payment for work, preserve the request, invoice, delivery records and evidence of use. A local lawyer can assess the available claim, the time limit and evidence of value. This guide provides general legal information.
Sources

About the author
Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.
