Section 73 of the Indian Contract Act on Damages for Breach
By Priya Pillai
In this article
- Start with breach and work through the loss
- The same missed delivery and two different losses
- Malini buys replacement stock for ₹8,000 more
- Hassan's unusually profitable order was never disclosed
- What the Supreme Court required as proof
- Section 73 and Section 74 answer different questions
- Use the correct place, date and goods
- Sources
Start with breach and work through the loss
- Identify what performance should have delivered. State the contractual obligation, when it was due and how it was broken. Ask what financial position proper performance would have produced.
- Connect the loss to that breach. Separate losses caused by the breach from losses the claimant would have suffered anyway.
- Apply the remoteness rule at formation. Loss may arise naturally in the usual course or be the likely result the parties knew when they made the contract. If the claim depends on an unusual order or deadline, establish what the parties knew at that time.
- Account for reasonable alternatives and prove the figure. Section 73's Explanation requires the available means of remedying the inconvenience to be considered. For a goods claim, obtain timely evidence of the relevant market or the cost of a reasonable replacement on the facts.
Mitigation affects the amount recoverable. The question is what loss the claimant could reasonably have avoided after the breach. Start with commercially available alternatives in the claimant's circumstances.
The same missed delivery and two different losses
Malini buys replacement stock for ₹8,000 more
Malini agrees to buy 200 bags of flour at ₹400 each, delivered on Monday in Pune. The supplier fails to deliver. Assume comparable stock in the relevant market costs ₹440 per bag and Malini buys it promptly at that price. The breach requires her to pay another ₹40 per bag for equivalent performance. On those facts, the market-price difference supports an ₹8,000 claim before any other adjustment.
Hassan's unusually profitable order was never disclosed
Hassan buys packaging at an ordinary wholesale price. The seller has no reason when contracting to know Hassan needs that batch to fulfil a one-off export order at an exceptional margin. The goods arrive late and the customer cancels. If that lost profit would neither ordinarily follow from the delay nor have been known to be likely by the parties, it is too remote. Hassan would still have to identify and prove any separate ordinary loss.
What the Supreme Court required as proof
Murlidhar Chiranjilal v. Harishchandra Dwarkadas, AIR 1962 SC 366, concerned a canvas sale with delivery by railway receipt on free-on-rail terms at Kanpur for shipment to Calcutta. The Court said the ordinary measure on those facts was the difference between the contract price and the market price for the relevant goods at Kanpur when the breach occurred. The buyer's proof of a price at Calcutta could not establish that amount.
In Unibros v. All India Radio, 2023 INSC 931, the Court upheld the setting aside of the lost-profit portion of an arbitral award. A construction delay and a formula did not suffice without evidence that a profit-making opportunity had been lost. The case shows why identifying a plausible percentage cannot replace the evidence needed for the claim.
Section 73 and Section 74 answer different questions
| Provision | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Section 73 | Loss caused by breach, the remoteness rule, reasonable mitigation and evidence of the amount. |
| Section 74 | A sum named for breach or a penalty stipulation, with reasonable compensation capped by the named sum or penalty. |
For a contract with an agreed amount, see the Section 74 guide. English sales law likewise uses a delivery-date market comparison as a prima facie measure in certain non-delivery cases under Section 51 of the Sale of Goods Act 1979.
Use the correct place, date and goods
For an exam answer, state the obligation and breach, identify each loss, apply the ordinary or known-loss branch and deduct the loss reasonably avoidable on the facts. Explain where your price evidence comes from and give a figure if the question supports one.
For an actual dispute, keep the agreement, notices, replacement quotes and records of what was communicated at formation. An Indian lawyer can assess any contractual limits and filing deadlines. This guide provides general legal information.
Sources

About the author
Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.
