LegalFly

Liquidated Damages and Penalties Under Section 74

In this article
  1. Establish the breach before calculating compensation
  2. Two delay clauses under the same section
  3. A late controller disrupts a production line
  4. A missing cabinet handle triggers a large fee
  5. How the Supreme Court treats the specified amount
  6. Compare the two kinds of stipulation
  7. Show your work on the amount
  8. If a contract charge is in dispute
  9. Sources
p>Section 74 of the Indian Contract Act generally allows reasonable compensation when a contract fixes a sum on breach or contains a penalty. The named sum or stipulated penalty sets the upper limit. Where loss is hard to quantify, a genuine advance estimate can support an award. A clause calling the sum liquidated damages does not make it automatically payable.

Establish the breach before calculating compensation

  1. Identify the trigger. Show that a contract was broken and that the breach is the one the clause covers. A fixed amount for a different breach cannot establish a right to compensation under that clause.
  2. Show the loss caused by the breach. Kailash Nath Associates treats damage or loss as necessary for compensation. In an ordinary commercial claim, if actual loss can be proved, the stipulated figure does not dispense with proof. Where loss is difficult or impossible to prove, the court can use a genuine advance estimate to support reasonable compensation.
  3. Apply the ceiling. The court assesses what compensation is reasonable, up to the amount named or penalty stipulated. Look at the clause's calculation, the likely loss and the evidence of what happened. The parties' label does not decide the result. The section separately requires payment of the full sum for breach of a bail bond, recognizance or other bond covered by its public duty exception.

Two delay clauses under the same section

A late controller disrupts a production line

Rao Engineering must replace a controller on Tara's packing line by 1 August. Both parties estimate that a shutdown would cost at least ₹20,000 a week, based on past outages. The contract sets that amount for each week of delay. Rao delivers two weeks late and the line is down throughout. Tara shows the disruption and the basis for the estimate, but the exact lost margin cannot be calculated reliably from the records. A court could use the genuine estimate and award up to ₹40,000 if it finds that sum reasonable.

A missing cabinet handle triggers a large fee

A separate contract claims ₹5,00,000 for any defect in a storage cabinet. Vivek delivers a cabinet missing a handle. Isha proves that a replacement and fitting cost ₹1,200. Assume she can prove her full loss and has no other recoverable loss. The missing part is a breach, but the clause does not entitle Isha to ₹5,00,000. On those facts, the repair cost supports a much smaller award.

How the Supreme Court treats the specified amount

Fateh Chand v. Balkishan Das, AIR 1963 SC 1405, applied Section 74 to a forfeiture claim under a sale agreement. The Court explained that it is for the court to award reasonable compensation subject to the contractual ceiling. The rule can apply to a penalty framed as forfeiture of money already paid.

ONGC Ltd. v. Saw Pipes Ltd., (2003) 5 SCC 705, recognised the relevance of a genuine pre-estimate in a delayed delivery dispute. Kailash Nath Associates v. Delhi Development Authority, (2015) 4 SCC 136, explains the limit. A genuine estimate can help when loss is difficult to prove. It does not replace proof when loss can be established, and Section 74 still requires loss caused by breach.

In Saisudhir Energy Ltd. v. NTPC Vidyut Vyapar Nigam Ltd., 2026 INSC 103, the Supreme Court addressed delay in a public utility project. It explained that where public utility losses are hard to quantify and the parties have stipulated liquidated damages, the party in breach bears the burden of showing that no loss resulted or that the stipulated sum was penal.

Compare the two kinds of stipulation

ClauseWhat the court can do under Section 74
Genuine estimate of the expected lossUse the estimate in assessing reasonable compensation, especially when actual loss is difficult to prove.
Penalty disproportionate to the expected lossAward reasonable compensation up to the stipulated amount, with proof of loss where it is possible.

English law asks whether a secondary obligation imposes a detriment out of all proportion to the innocent party's legitimate interest in performance, as explained in Cavendish. For an Indian problem, apply Section 74's requirement of reasonable compensation.

Show your work on the amount

Identify the breach and match it to the clause. State the Section 74 ceiling and the proof rule from Kailash Nath. Use the evidence to explain what was lost and whether the agreed estimate helps measure it. Conclude with the amount the evidence supports. If the dispute is about whether any breach occurred because performance became impossible, start with the guide to frustration.

If a contract charge is in dispute

Keep the signed contract, any extensions, notices and records of what the delay or defect cost. Check the deadlines in the governing agreement and seek advice from a local contract lawyer. A general explanation of Section 74 cannot settle what a particular clause covers or what evidence is available.

Sources

Priya Pillai

About the author

Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.

More from PriyaLegalFly on YouTube