Theft vs Criminal Breach of Trust Under the BNS
By Priya Pillai
In this article
- Check possession and entrustment before applying either section
- The evidentiary question changes with the charge
- A borrowed key and money entrusted for a purchase
- Sana takes a camera from a locked cabinet
- Arvind spends money he was given to pay a supplier
- Access, custody and entrustment
- Take the facts in the order they happened
- Sources
Check possession and entrustment before applying either section
- For theft, identify the property and possession. The property must be movable and in another person's possession. Ownership and possession can be held by different people. Identify who was in possession when the property moved.
- Check dishonest intention, movement and consent. Section 303 requires dishonest intention to take it and movement in order to do so without express or implied consent from the possessor or someone authorised to give it. Section 2(7) defines dishonesty through an intention to cause wrongful gain or wrongful loss.
- For criminal breach of trust, identify the entrustment. Section 316 requires property or dominion over property to have been entrusted to the accused. Find what was entrusted, to whom and for what purpose.
- Identify the dishonest dealing. The section covers dishonest misappropriation or conversion to one's own use, or dishonest use or disposal contrary to a direction of law or a legal contract governing discharge of the trust. It also addresses wilfully allowing someone else to do so. An ordinary missed payment by itself does not establish the offence.
The evidentiary question changes with the charge
| Question | Theft | Criminal breach of trust |
|---|---|---|
| Current and former provision | Section 303 BNS, formerly IPC Sections 378 and 379 for the general offence. | Section 316 BNS, formerly IPC Sections 405 and 406 for the general offence. |
| What must be shown about the property? | Movable property in another person's possession. | Entrustment of property or dominion over it. |
| What act matters? | Moving it without consent in order to take it dishonestly. | A dishonest dealing of the kind specified by Section 316 with the entrusted property. |
A borrowed key and money entrusted for a purchase
Sana takes a camera from a locked cabinet
Sana is allowed to use a key to open a store's cabinet for an inventory count. The store remains in possession of the equipment inside. Assume Sana takes a camera without consent intending to keep it, and that the camera or dominion over it was never entrusted to her. Permission to count the items does not extend to taking the camera. The facts support theft. They do not establish the entrustment required for criminal breach of trust.
Arvind spends money he was given to pay a supplier
A residents' association gives Arvind ₹30,000 to hold and pay on its behalf to a specified supplier. He knowingly takes the money for his personal use instead. The handover was consensual, and the money was entrusted for a limited purpose. The dishonest conversion supports a Section 316 allegation. If he had merely paid late while keeping the funds for their proper purpose, delay alone would not establish dishonest dealing.
Access, custody and entrustment
In Pyare Lal Bhargava v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1963 SC 1094, the Supreme Court upheld a theft conviction involving temporary removal of an official file that was later returned. The original IPC case illustrates why temporary movement can suffice if the required dishonest intention is present.
In Sudhir Shantilal Mehta v. CBI, (2009) 8 SCC 1, the Supreme Court distinguished entrustment or dominion from the later dishonest dealing that former Section 405 IPC required. It applied that definition when considering the aggravated offence under former Section 409 IPC.
In England and Wales, the Theft Act 1968 uses the concept of dishonest appropriation with intent permanently to deprive, subject to its statutory elaboration of that intent. Section 4 of the Fraud Act 2006 covers dishonest abuse of a position in which someone is expected to safeguard or refrain from acting against another’s financial interests, with intent to gain, cause loss or expose someone to a risk of loss. Apply the BNS wording to an Indian problem.
Take the facts in the order they happened
Identify possession and consent at the moment the item moved. Check whether property or control had been entrusted before the alleged misuse, and explain the evidence of dishonesty. Distinguish the case where a victim hands over property in response to a threat using the theft and extortion comparison. For a real dispute, preserve the instructions, receipts and chronology and speak with a local lawyer. This guide provides general legal information.
Sources
- Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, Sections 2(7), 303 and 316.
- Pyare Lal Bhargava v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1963 SC 1094.
- Sudhir Shantilal Mehta v. CBI, (2009) 8 SCC 1.
- Theft Act 1968 (UK), read with Section 6.
- Fraud Act 2006 (UK), Section 4.

About the author
Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.
