LegalFly

Theft vs. Extortion: Key Differences, Punishment & Case Law

Theft vs. Extortion: Key Differences, Punishment & Case Law

In short

Theft under Section 303 BNS involves moving movable property with the intent to take it dishonestly out of someone's possession without consent. Extortion under Section 308 BNS involves intentionally causing fear of injury and using that fear to dishonestly induce someone to hand something over.

In this brief
  1. BNS Sections 303 and 308 and their IPC equivalents
  2. What is theft?
  3. Key elements of theft
  4. Example of theft
  5. What is extortion?
  6. Key elements of extortion
  7. Example of extortion
  8. Theft vs. extortion: the key differences
  9. The role of consent
  10. The role of intention
  11. Punishment for theft and extortion
  12. Landmark case law
  13. Conclusion
  14. Watch: the difference between theft and extortion
  15. Sources

Theft is defined in Section 303(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023 (formerly Section 378 IPC). It involves dishonestly moving movable property to take it out of another person's possession without consent. Extortion is defined in Section 308(1) BNS (formerly Section 383 IPC). It involves intentionally putting someone in fear of injury and using that fear to dishonestly induce them to hand something over.

BNS Sections 303 and 308 and their IPC equivalents

Sections 303 and 308 of the BNS came into force on 1 July 2024. Use the IPC column when reading judgments under the old law. Section 358 BNS preserves liability and proceedings for offences committed under the IPC.

What the provision coversBNS, 2023Old IPCBNS punishment
Theft definition303(1)378See Section 303(2)
Ordinary theft303(2)379Up to 3 years in prison, a fine, or both. Special rules apply to repeat convictions and qualifying first convictions.
Extortion definition308(1)383See Section 308(2)
Ordinary extortion308(2)384Up to 7 years in prison, a fine, or both
Putting or attempting to put someone in fear of injury in order to extort308(3)385Up to 2 years in prison, a fine, or both
Putting or attempting to put someone in fear of death or grievous hurt in order to extort308(4)387Up to 7 years in prison and liability to a fine
Extortion committed by causing fear of death or grievous hurt308(5)386Up to 10 years in prison and liability to a fine
Putting or attempting to put someone in fear of a qualifying criminal accusation in order to extort308(6)389Up to 10 years in prison and liability to a fine
Extortion committed by causing fear of a qualifying criminal accusation308(7)388Up to 10 years in prison and liability to a fine

Sections 308(6) and (7) concern accusations of committing or attempting an offence punishable with death, life imprisonment or a term that may extend to ten years. Section 308(7) also covers an accusation of attempting to induce someone else to commit such an offence. See the text of Sections 303 and 308 and the NCRB's BNS-to-IPC comparison table.

Theft vs. Extortion under Indian law

What is theft?

Under Section 303(1) BNS (formerly Section 378 IPC), theft occurs when someone moves movable property intending to take it dishonestly out of another person's possession without that person's consent.

Key elements of theft

  • Dishonest intention. The taker intends to cause wrongful gain to someone or wrongful loss to someone. See Section 2(7) BNS (formerly Section 24 IPC).
  • Movable property. A phone, cash or a vehicle can be stolen. Something attached to the earth, such as a tree, can become the subject of theft once it is severed.
  • Lack of consent. The person in possession has given neither express nor implied consent, and no one authorised to consent on their behalf has given it.
  • Movement. The property must be moved in order to take it. Permanent deprivation is unnecessary.

Example of theft

At a coffee shop, Meera leaves her phone on the table while reading. Ravi sees that she is distracted, slides the phone off the table and puts it in his bag intending to keep it.

Ravi intends a wrongful gain. The phone is movable property in Meera's possession, she has given no consent, and Ravi moves it in order to take it. On those facts, the theft is complete when he moves the phone.

What is extortion?

Section 308(1) BNS (formerly Section 383 IPC) requires an intentional act that puts someone in fear of injury to themselves or another person. The offender must use that fear to dishonestly induce the person to deliver property, a valuable security, or a signed or sealed item that can be converted into a valuable security.

For the next distinction, see when extortion becomes robbery under BNS Section 309.

Key elements of extortion

  • Intentionally causing fear. The offender deliberately puts the person in fear of injury. Injury includes harm illegally caused to body, mind, reputation or property. See Section 2(14) BNS (formerly Section 44 IPC).
  • Dishonest inducement. The offender uses that fear to induce the person to hand something over.
  • Delivery. The person delivers the property, valuable security or qualifying signed or sealed item because of the fear. The recipient can be the offender or another person.

Example of extortion

Ravi texts Meera from home and demands ₹10,000. He threatens to break her shop window that night if she refuses. Afraid that he will damage her shop, Meera transfers the money.

Ravi deliberately causes fear of injury to Meera's property. He uses the threat to obtain money dishonestly, and Meera transfers the money because she fears the damage. Those facts illustrate completed extortion under Section 308(1) BNS (formerly Section 383 IPC). If she refuses to pay, Section 308(3) BNS (formerly Section 385 IPC) can still apply to the threat made in order to extort.

Theft vs. extortion: the key differences

QuestionTheftExtortion
How is the property obtained?The offender moves it to take it out of another person's possession without consent.The person delivers it because the offender put them in fear of injury.
Must the person be afraid?No.Yes, for completed extortion.
What can the offence involve?Movable property.Property, a valuable security, or a signed or sealed item that can become a valuable security.
What is the ordinary maximum prison term?3 years under Section 303(2) BNS (formerly Section 379 IPC).7 years under Section 308(2) BNS (formerly Section 384 IPC, which set a maximum of 3 years).
Key differences between theft and extortion

When the accused had been entrusted with the property, the theft and criminal breach of trust guide explains what changes under Section 316 BNS.

In theft, the person in possession has not consented to the taking. They might see the item being taken and object. In completed extortion, the person hands it over in response to the fear the offender created.

The role of intention

Both offences require dishonesty, which involves an intent to cause wrongful gain or wrongful loss. Extortion also requires intentionally causing fear of injury and using that fear to induce delivery.

Punishment for theft and extortion

Under Section 303(2) BNS (formerly Section 379 IPC), ordinary theft carries up to three years in prison, a fine, or both. On a second or subsequent conviction under Section 303, the punishment is one to five years of rigorous imprisonment and a fine. On a first conviction, if the property is worth less than ₹5,000 and the offender returns the property or its value, the provision requires community service.

Section 308(2) BNS (formerly Section 384 IPC) provides for up to seven years in prison, a fine, or both for ordinary extortion. The penalties for threats made in order to extort and for aggravated extortion depend on the particular subsection in the table above.

The BNS also treats snatching as a distinct theft offence under Section 304. It involves suddenly, quickly or forcibly taking movable property from a person or their possession, and has no standalone IPC equivalent. Sections 305 and 306 BNS cover specified thefts such as theft in a dwelling (formerly Section 380 IPC) and theft by a clerk or servant of property in an employer's possession (formerly Section 381 IPC).

Landmark case law

  1. In Pyare Lal Bhargava v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1963 SC 1094, a government employee removed an official file, passed it to someone else and returned it the next day. The Supreme Court held that temporary dispossession could amount to theft under Section 378 IPC.
  2. In R.S. Nayak v. A.R. Antulay, AIR 1986 SC 2045, the Court declined to direct that an extortion charge be framed. The evidence that sugar co-operatives had been pressed to donate did not show that they paid because they had been put in fear of injury.
  3. In Romesh Chandra Arora v. The State, AIR 1960 SC 154, the accused sought money by threatening to circulate intimate photographs. The Supreme Court upheld a conviction for criminal intimidation under Section 506 IPC. The judgment illustrates a threat to reputation made to demand payment.

Conclusion

For theft, ask who moved the property and whether the person in possession consented. For completed extortion, ask what injury the person feared and whether that fear caused them to hand something over.

Watch: the difference between theft and extortion

Watch our walkthrough of the difference between theft and extortion.

Sources

Priya Pillai

About the author

Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.

More from PriyaLegalFly on YouTube