When Does Extortion Become Robbery? BNS Section 309
By Priya Pillai
In this article
What Section 309(3) adds to extortion
- Start with Section 308(1) BNS (former IPC Section 383). The offender intentionally puts a person in fear of injury to that person or someone else and thereby dishonestly induces the person to deliver property, a valuable security or a signed or sealed thing that can become a valuable security. Delivery can be to any person.
- Check presence and the specific fear. Under Section 309(3) BNS (the extortion branch of former IPC Section 390), the offender must be present. The explanation asks whether the offender is sufficiently near to create the specified fear. The harm feared must be instant death, hurt or wrongful restraint. The feared harm may be to the person put in fear or to someone else.
- Check the handover. The person put in fear must deliver the thing then and there because of that fear. A demand can fail to produce a completed robbery while leaving a separate question of attempt or extortion-related liability under the statute.
Change the timing and the result changes
Neel stops a delivery rider at the gate
Neel stands within arm's reach of Asha at an apartment gate. He demands the cash in her delivery pouch and raises a heavy wrench to strike her immediately unless she hands it over. Asha hands him the pouch on the spot because she fears the blow. The threat is intended to obtain the cash dishonestly. Neel is present, the feared hurt is instant, and the handover follows immediately. Those facts satisfy the extortion branch of robbery.
Farah gets a demand over the phone
From another city, Ravi tells Farah he will smash her shopfront next week unless she transfers money he knows he has no right to demand. Farah pays during the call because of the threat. The payment is immediate, but Ravi is absent and the threatened damage is in the future. The facts support extortion under Section 308(1). They lack the added facts Section 309(3) requires for robbery.
Which route did the offender take?
| Offence | What happens to the property | What fear or force must be shown |
|---|---|---|
| Extortion, Section 308(1) | The frightened person is dishonestly induced to deliver it. | Intentional fear of injury that causes delivery. |
| Robbery by extortion, Section 309(3) | The frightened person delivers it then and there. | Presence and fear of instant death, hurt or wrongful restraint. |
| Robbery by theft, Section 309(2) | The offender commits theft. | Voluntarily causing or attempting to cause death, hurt, wrongful restraint or fear of their instant occurrence. This must further the theft or the carrying or attempted carrying away of what was stolen. |
Section 309(2) also covers the specified conduct during the theft when it is done for that end. A shove that deliberately causes bodily pain so the offender can take a bag can be part of robbery by theft even if the victim never handed it over. Start by asking who moved or delivered the property.
A weapon can matter after robbery is established
In Phool Kumar v. Delhi Administration, (1975) 1 SCC 797, the Supreme Court interpreted former IPC Section 397. A deadly weapon in the victim's view and capable of causing terror could count as use even if the offender did not strike with it. The case concerns the aggravated punishment provision, whose BNS counterpart is Section 311. It does not remove the elements of robbery under Section 309.
In England and Wales, Section 8 of the Theft Act 1968 defines robbery through stealing by using force, putting someone in fear of immediate force or seeking to put them in that fear. The conduct must occur immediately before or during the stealing and be for the purpose of stealing. India's Section 309 expressly provides separate theft and extortion routes.
Apply the elements in order
Begin with the disputed classification and state the elements from Sections 308(1) and 309(3). Work through the injury feared, the offender’s proximity and how the fear caused delivery then and there. Classify the completed offence before addressing attempt. The relevant BNS provisions took effect on 1 July 2024. For earlier incidents, check the IPC and the BNS saving provision in Section 358.
If you received a threat
Prioritise your safety. If safe to do so, keep the original messages and any payment records. Contact the police or seek advice from a local lawyer or legal services authority. The legal classification depends on the facts, including what was threatened and whether anyone delivered property.
Sources
- Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, Sections 1, 303, 308, 309, 311 and 358.
- Ministry of Home Affairs, parliamentary reply on commencement of the new criminal laws.
- National Crime Records Bureau, BNS to IPC correspondence table.
- Indian Penal Code, 1860, Sections 383, 390 and 397.
- Phool Kumar v. Delhi Administration, (1975) 1 SCC 797.
- Theft Act 1968 (UK), Section 8.
- National Legal Services Authority, legal aid information.

About the author
Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.
