LegalFly

The Basic Structure Doctrine in India

In this article
  1. How to test a constitutional amendment
  2. Two limits on the amending power
  3. Two amendments to analyse
  4. The amending power is put beyond judicial review
  5. A change to the terms of local bodies
  6. Four decisions that show how the doctrine works
  7. Start the exam answer with the instrument under challenge
  8. A comparison with parliamentary sovereignty in the UK
  9. Sources

The basic structure doctrine limits Parliament's power to amend the Indian Constitution under Article 368. Parliament can change constitutional provisions, including those on fundamental rights. An amendment is invalid to the extent it damages or destroys a basic feature, such as judicial review or the limited character of the amending power itself.

How to test a constitutional amendment

  1. Read the amendment and check the procedure. Under Article 368, each House must pass the bill by a majority of its total membership and by at least two-thirds of the members present and voting. For changes to certain provisions, the legislatures of at least half the States must ratify the bill before it goes to the President for assent.
  2. Identify the basic feature at risk. Name the feature, show how the Constitution gives it effect and cite a case recognising it. For example, Minerva Mills treats limited amending power as a basic feature.
  3. Examine what the amendment does to the feature. Ask how institutions and rights would work after the change. The loss of a safeguard may matter more than how many words or articles Parliament amended.

The Court's judgments identify features such as constitutional supremacy, democracy, federalism, secularism and judicial review. The decided cases supply examples of basic features. A question about another feature calls for an argument grounded in the Constitution and the judgments.

Two limits on the amending power

LimitWhat you examineExample
Article 368 procedureWhat passed each House, whether any State ratification was required and whether the President assented.A change to the distribution of legislative powers in the Seventh Schedule requires State ratification.
Basic structureThe amendment's effect on a basic feature of the Constitution.A clause taking away all judicial review of constitutional amendments threatens the courts' ability to enforce the limits on Parliament.

Two amendments to analyse

The amending power is put beyond judicial review

Parliament follows the Article 368 procedure, including State ratification, and adds a clause barring every court from reviewing any constitutional amendment. Asha challenges it after the amendment takes effect.

The procedure is satisfied. The feature at risk is judicial review, particularly review of the limits on the amending power. The clause would let Parliament decide for itself whether it had exceeded those limits. Under Minerva Mills, Asha has a strong case for striking down the clause.

A change to the terms of local bodies

Ravi challenges an amendment reducing the ordinary term of municipalities under Article 243U from five years to four. Assume it meets the applicable Article 368 procedure, preserves regular competitive elections and leaves the rest of the system intact.

Ravi can identify democracy as the feature at issue. On these facts, the change shortens the term officials serve before facing voters again. Nothing in the hypothetical shows that the amendment damages democratic government. His basic structure challenge would therefore be unlikely to succeed.

Four decisions that show how the doctrine works

  • Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala, (1973) 4 SCC 225. The 13-judge Bench upheld the Twenty-fourth Amendment and held by a narrow majority that the amending power cannot be used to alter the Constitution's basic structure. The judges gave separate reasons. The case brief explains how the land reform dispute reached the Court.
  • Minerva Mills Ltd. v. Union of India, (1980) 3 SCC 625. The Court struck down clauses (4) and (5) inserted into Article 368. One excluded review of amendments and the other claimed unlimited amending power. The majority also invalidated the expansion of Article 31C to cover laws giving effect to any Directive Principle. The Court treated the balance between fundamental rights and Directive Principles as part of the basic structure. See the Minerva Mills case brief.
  • I.R. Coelho v. State of Tamil Nadu, (2007) 2 SCC 1. A nine-judge Bench held that amendments placing laws in the Ninth Schedule on or after 24 April 1973 can be reviewed for damage to the basic structure. Courts examine whether the protected law infringes rights in a way that damages the basic structure. The judgment preserves the finality of Supreme Court decisions that already upheld the validity of a Ninth Schedule law.
  • Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India, (2016) 5 SCC 1. The majority invalidated the Ninety-ninth Amendment establishing the National Judicial Appointments Commission, and the related legislation. Its reasons addressed the protection of judicial independence in the appointments process.

For Article 31C, distinguish the expansion struck down in Minerva Mills from the narrower protection for laws implementing Article 39(b) or (c). In Property Owners Association v. State of Maharashtra, 2024 INSC 835, the Court held that Article 31C survives to the extent upheld in Kesavananda Bharati. Courts can still examine whether the law genuinely serves Article 39(b) or (c) before the protection from Articles 14 and 19 challenges applies.

Start the exam answer with the instrument under challenge

Identify whether the problem concerns an ordinary Act or an Article 368 amendment. In Kuldip Nayar v. Union of India, the Court explained that an ordinary statute faces review against constitutional provisions. Courts can also ask whether the legislature had the power to enact it, as Anjum Kadari reaffirmed. The basic structure doctrine is a limit on the amending power. For an ordinary law that sorts people into groups, the constitutional question may be reasonable classification under Article 14.

  1. Issue. Identify the amendment and the feature it allegedly damages.
  2. Rule. Give the Article 368 procedure and the substantive limit from Kesavananda Bharati.
  3. Application. Check the procedure and trace the amendment's effect on the institutions or protections in question. If a Ninth Schedule entry is involved, give its date and apply I.R. Coelho.
  4. Conclusion. Identify the part of the amendment that is likely to survive or fail, and give the reason.

A comparison with parliamentary sovereignty in the UK

The UK Supreme Court described parliamentary sovereignty in Miller as the principle that laws enacted by the Crown in Parliament are the supreme form of domestic law. The case concerned ministers' power to prorogue Parliament. India's doctrine addresses an additional question posed by a written constitution with a defined amendment power.

Sources

Priya Pillai

About the author

Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.

More from PriyaLegalFly on YouTube