Reasonable Classification Under Article 14: Worked Examples
By Priya Pillai
In this article
- The two-part test
- The same benefit, two different classifications
- A grant for shops in flood-hit wards
- The grant goes only to shops with even-numbered addresses
- What the leading cases decided
- Classification and manifest arbitrariness
- An IRAC answer for Article 14
- A comparison with U.S. equal protection
- Sources
Article 14 of the Indian Constitution allows the State to treat groups differently if the classification meets two conditions. An intelligible differentia must distinguish those included from those excluded. That difference must have a rational nexus to the law's purpose. A clear boundary between groups can still fail if it has nothing to do with that purpose.
The two-part test
Article 14 guarantees equality before the law and equal protection of the laws to every person. In Budhan Choudhry v. State of Bihar, the Supreme Court explained the two questions courts ask when the State treats groups differently, including differences in legal procedure.
- Intelligible differentia. Identify the real distinction on which the rule separates the groups. A rule might use occupation, geography or some other identifiable characteristic. Be specific about who falls on each side.
- Rational nexus. Identify the law's purpose and explain how the characteristic helps achieve it. The question is whether there is a rational connection between the distinction and the objective.
Ask what the rule actually does. A stated objective can be perfectly legitimate while the rule singles people out on grounds that do nothing to advance it. In Sukanya Shantha, the Court emphasised examining the real purpose and considering the substantive demands of equality.
The same benefit, two different classifications
A grant for shops in flood-hit wards
A State creates a grant to restore trading in flood-hit wards. Its rules cover shops whose ground floors were inundated in the flood. Leela's shop meets that condition. Omar's shop, in an unaffected ward, does not.
The intelligible differentia is inundation in the flood. The link to the object is direct. Site damage prevents those shops from reopening, and the grant pays for repairs. On those facts the rule would likely pass the classification test. If Omar could show that his shop suffered the same flood damage and the scheme excluded it solely because of an unexplained ward boundary, the comparison would be different.
The grant goes only to shops with even-numbered addresses
Suppose Leela and Omar have equally damaged shops on the same street. The State keeps the same repair objective and admits only shops at even-numbered addresses, including Leela's.
The numbers give the State an identifiable dividing line. Even if that line satisfies the first limb, the rule would likely fail the second. The address numbers tell the State nothing about flood damage or reopening a shop.
What the leading cases decided
- State of West Bengal v. Anwar Ali Sarkar, [1952] SCR 284. The majority rejected the State's power to send individual cases to special courts under the challenged provision. The aim of speedier trials did not supply an adequate standard for selecting the cases to receive different procedures.
- Budhan Choudhry v. State of Bihar, [1955] 1 SCR 1045. The Court set out the two conditions and rejected the Article 14 challenge to the operation of the criminal procedure provision in that case.
- Ram Krishna Dalmia v. Justice S.R. Tendolkar, [1959] SCR 279. A single person or entity can constitute a class if special circumstances distinguish it. The Court also recognised a presumption of constitutionality for legislation and examined whether statutory guidance controlled the power to select who would be subject to an inquiry.
- Sukanya Shantha v. Union of India, 2024 INSC 753. The Court struck down prison rules that discriminated on caste grounds, including rules assigning work by caste. Its Article 14 analysis also explains that a provision can be manifestly arbitrary without classifying anyone.
Classification and manifest arbitrariness
| Ground | Question to ask | Where to look |
|---|---|---|
| Unreasonable classification | What separates the groups, and why does it matter to the law's purpose? | The legal criterion, the comparator and the actual objective. |
| Manifest arbitrariness | Is the provision capricious, irrational, excessive and disproportionate, or lacking an adequate governing principle? | The provision's design and effect. The ground can apply even without a classification. |
The case brief on Joseph Shine gives an example of a challenge involving both unequal treatment and manifest arbitrariness. In a problem about eligibility rules, begin with the classification. If the facts also expose unbounded power or an irrational rule, analyse that separately. The Court in Sukanya Shantha considered other constitutional guarantees as well, including Article 15's specific prohibition on certain grounds of discrimination.
An IRAC answer for Article 14
- Issue. Identify the State measure, the favoured group and the person or group left out.
- Rule. State both limbs from Budhan Choudhry.
- Application. Write one sentence explaining how the law sorts people and another testing the connection to its real objective. Give the State's best answer before explaining whether it holds up.
- Conclusion. Say which limb decides the issue on the facts. Address any separate constitutional ground the problem raises.
A comparison is only as good as the fact that makes the groups similarly placed. For an example involving the age of retirement for officers of the armed forces, read the judgment in Union of India v. Atul Shukla, (2014) 10 SCC 432. For classifications written into the Constitution by amendment, see the separate question addressed by the basic structure doctrine.
A comparison with U.S. equal protection
In City of Cleburne v. Cleburne Living Center, the U.S. Supreme Court applied rational-basis review and rejected a city's permit requirement as applied to a group home for people with intellectual disabilities. U.S. equal protection also uses more demanding forms of review for some classifications. In an Indian Article 14 answer, start with the Indian authorities.
Sources
- Constitution of India, Articles 14 and 15.
- State of West Bengal v. Anwar Ali Sarkar, [1952] SCR 284.
- Budhan Choudhry v. State of Bihar, [1955] 1 SCR 1045.
- Ram Krishna Dalmia v. Justice S.R. Tendolkar, [1959] SCR 279.
- Union of India v. Atul Shukla, (2014) 10 SCC 432.
- Sukanya Shantha v. Union of India, 2024 INSC 753, especially paragraphs 24 to 34 and 231(i).
- City of Cleburne v. Cleburne Living Center, 473 U.S. 432 (1985).

About the author
Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.
