LegalFly

Compounding a Cheque Bounce Case Under Section 147

In this article
  1. Consent, payment and the court order
  2. Compounding costs after Sanjabij Tari
  3. What changes when the defence has given evidence
  4. Ravi and Leela agree after defence evidence
  5. Dev sends the money while his appeal is pending
  6. Three judgments to read together
  7. Work through consent before calculating costs
  8. Sources
p>Section 147 of the Negotiable Instruments Act allows a Section 138 cheque bounce case to end by compounding. It requires the complainant’s consent and a court order in a pending prosecution. Under Sanjabij Tari, the standard additional costs are zero before recording defence evidence and 5%, 7.5% or 10% at later stages.

Consent, payment and the court order

  1. Identify the prosecution. Section 138 creates the offence and Section 147 makes offences under the NI Act compoundable. Where civil recovery proceedings or other charges are also pending, check the terms and orders for those matters separately.
  2. Check the complainant's consent. The Supreme Court treated compounding as bilateral in JIK Industries and confirmed the consent requirement in A.S. Pharma. A payment or a settlement of the underlying debt does not, on its own, amount to the complainant's consent to compound the offence.
  3. Identify the stage and seek an order. The parties can put the agreement and evidence of payment before the court handling the matter. Sanjabij Tari ties the guideline costs to when the cheque amount is paid. If the case is on appeal following a conviction, the order should deal with the conviction as well.

Compounding costs after Sanjabij Tari

Paragraph 38 of Sanjabij Tari revised the 2010 Damodar Prabhu scale. These figures apply to the additional cost calculated on the cheque amount. They are separate from the payment of the cheque amount itself.

When the cheque amount is paidAdditional guideline costExtra on ₹2,00,000
Trial court, before recording defence evidenceTrial court may allow compounding without costs₹0 if allowed without costs
Trial court, after recording defence evidence and before judgment5%₹10,000
Sessions Court or High Court, in appeal or revision7.5%₹15,000
Supreme Court10%₹20,000

For the 5% trial-stage cost, the judgment directs payment to the Legal Services Authority or another authority the court sees fit. The court's order identifies the amount and where to pay it. The Bombay High Court has applied the court’s discretion to reduce or waive the revised costs for case-specific reasons recorded in writing. Paragraph 39 of Sanjabij Tari also discusses a separate route when the complainant asks for more than the cheque amount. The Magistrate may suggest a guilty plea and consider sentencing powers under Section 278 BNSS (or former Section 255(2) or (3) CrPC) or relief under the Probation of Offenders Act.

What changes when the defence has given evidence

Ravi and Leela agree after defence evidence

Ravi's ₹2,00,000 cheque is the subject of a Section 138 trial. Leela agrees to compound. Ravi pays the cheque amount after his evidence has been recorded and before judgment. At that stage the standard additional cost is ₹10,000. The Magistrate may allow compounding and direct where the additional cost is to be deposited.

Dev sends the money while his appeal is pending

Dev has been convicted at trial and pays the ₹2,00,000 cheque amount during a Sessions Court appeal. The ordinary guideline cost at that stage is ₹15,000. Mira declines to agree to compounding. The transfer and Dev's willingness to pay costs do not supply her consent or set aside the conviction. The appeal remains for the court to deal with.

Three judgments to read together

The percentage scale comes from India's NI Act cases. In England and Wales, for comparison, a false representation involving payment may raise a separate question under Section 2 of the Fraud Act 2006, which requires dishonesty and the specified intent.

Work through consent before calculating costs

In a problem question, identify the Section 138 proceedings, cite Section 147 and explain whether the complainant consented. Identify when payment was made and which court has the case. Calculate the applicable guideline cost and state what order the parties would need. The Section 138 guide explains notice requirements and the underlying offence. The Damodar Prabhu case brief explains the original scale.

If you are a party to a pending case, keep the signed settlement, payment records and court notices. A local lawyer can help you check hearing and appeal deadlines and establish whether the court has recorded the settlement. Eligible parties can seek help through their District Legal Services Authority. This guide provides general legal information.

Sources

Priya Pillai

About the author

Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.

More from PriyaLegalFly on YouTube