LegalFly

Doctrine of Manifest Arbitrariness Under Article 14

In this article
  1. Identify the rule and the principle that is supposed to justify it
  2. Compare a rule with no guiding standard and one with a public purpose
  3. The audit law gives the minister unrestricted power to close archives
  4. The same law pauses physical access during flood repairs
  5. From triple talaq to corporate political donations
  6. Reasonable classification and manifest arbitrariness
  7. Give the strongest justification before testing it
  8. Sources
p>The doctrine of manifest arbitrariness allows Indian courts to invalidate legislation under Article 14 when it is capricious, irrational, lacks an adequate governing principle, or is excessive and disproportionate. The court examines the provision's real purpose and effect. A challenge can succeed even where the law draws no express distinction between groups.

Identify the rule and the principle that is supposed to justify it

  1. Read the operative text. Identify who is subject to the rule, what it requires and how it works. A statutory objective stated in broad terms does not answer what the particular provision does.
  2. Examine the real purpose. Ask which principle explains the design of the measure and whether its actual purpose is in consonance with constitutional values. Compare the purpose the State claims with what the text and available material show.
  3. Show the defect in the design or effect. Explain why the measure is capricious, irrational or both excessive and disproportionate in the circumstances. A plausible competing policy is different from showing that the enacted rule is constitutionally defective.
  4. Distinguish an Act from a rule made under it. For subordinate legislation, the Court assesses manifest arbitrariness primarily by reference to the parent statute. A failure to consider a vital factor that the Constitution or the statute expressly or by necessary implication requires can matter to that inquiry. An Act passed by a competent legislature receives greater deference than a rule made by a delegate.

Compare a rule with no guiding standard and one with a public purpose

The audit law gives the minister unrestricted power to close archives

A fictional Act aims to preserve municipal records. It lets the minister permanently close any public archive and end public access without supplying criteria, even where no records are at risk. Leena identifies how the power works and asks what principle connects permanent closure to record preservation. Assume no other provision supplies a standard or limits the power. The lack of guidance and severity of the effect support an Article 14 challenge, even though the power can be used against any archive.

The same law pauses physical access during flood repairs

Consider a narrower provision that closes an archive for up to 30 days when a documented flood has made the building unsafe, preserves digital access and requires an early reopening if repairs finish. Arjun would prefer a shorter maximum. The safety trigger, duration and reopening requirement supply a reasoned basis for the rule. On these facts his preference alone does not establish manifest arbitrariness.

From triple talaq to corporate political donations

  • Shayara Bano v. Union of India, (2017) 9 SCC 1. Justices Nariman and Lalit articulated the test in the case on instant triple talaq. The practice was set aside by a 3–2 result, with Justice Kurian Joseph reaching that result on separate reasoning.
  • Association for Democratic Reforms v. Union of India, 2024 INSC 113. The Constitution Bench held that the amendment deleting the cap on corporate political contributions under Section 182(1) of the Companies Act was manifestly arbitrary. It also explained that the inquiry is available even where the provision makes no classification.
  • Anurag Krishna Sinha v. State of Bihar, 2026 INSC 219. The Court struck down a State law that permanently took over an institute and library, vested their assets in the State and extinguished the managing trust. It confirmed manifest arbitrariness as a ground for legislative review, stressed judicial restraint and also found a violation of Article 300A.

Reasonable classification and manifest arbitrariness

Article 14 inquiryWhat to test
Reasonable classificationAsk whether the law draws an intelligible distinction between the groups and whether that distinction has a rational connection to the object.
Manifest arbitrarinessIdentify the provision's purpose, the principle guiding it and whether it is capricious, irrational or excessive and disproportionate. The inquiry can apply even without a classification.

Give the strongest justification before testing it

State the Article 14 issue and identify the particular text the claimant challenges. Explain the strongest justification for its design and test it against the way the provision actually works. If the rule comes from a delegate, start with the governing Act and apply the limits on delegated legislation. Conclude on the provision you analysed, taking care to distinguish the reasons supported by a majority from a separate opinion.

Sources

Priya Pillai

About the author

Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.

More from PriyaLegalFly on YouTube