Frustration of Contract in India Under Section 56
By Priya Pillai
In this article
- When does Section 56 discharge a contract?
- Force majeure under Section 32 and frustration under Section 56
- A banned event and a more expensive delivery
- The only date is prohibited by a binding order
- An ordinary shipping route closes
- What the Supreme Court decided
- What happens to advances under Section 65?
- Start with the promise in the exam problem
- The English comparison
- If an event has interrupted your contract
- Sources
Under Section 56 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a contract becomes void when an event after formation makes the promised act impossible or, because of an event the promisor could not prevent, unlawful. Impossibility can include the collapse of the bargain's foundation. If the contract itself deals with the event, start with its terms and Section 32.
When does Section 56 discharge a contract?
- Identify the promise and when the contract was made. The second paragraph of Section 56 concerns an event after formation. The first paragraph separately makes an agreement to do an inherently impossible act void.
- Read the contract for an allocation of the risk. If a term governs what happens when the event occurs, apply that term. Energy Watchdog treats contractual force majeure under the rules on contingent contracts, particularly Section 32.
- Trace the effect of the event on performance. Ask whether the promised act became impossible or became unlawful because of an event the promisor could not prevent. Under Satyabrata Ghose, impossibility can include a change that makes performance useless in light of the purpose on which both parties based their bargain.
- Test practical alternatives. Consider substitutes or methods that still meet the promise, along with the length of any delay and the importance of the date. Unexpected cost or hardship alone is insufficient.
Force majeure under Section 32 and frustration under Section 56
| Question | Contractual force majeure | Statutory frustration |
|---|---|---|
| Where does the relief come from? | The contract's allocation of the risk, read with the Act's rules on contingent contracts. | The second paragraph of Section 56. |
| What must you establish? | That the event and its effect fall within the contract's terms and any conditions for claiming relief are met. | That the supervening event made the agreed performance impossible or unlawful in the statutory sense. |
| What happens to the obligation? | Read the clause. It may allow extra time, suspend the obligation or provide for termination. | The contract becomes void when the promised act becomes impossible or unlawful. |
A force majeure clause can cover one kind of disruption and leave another risk with the supplier. The label given to the event matters less than the clause's trigger and what it says about performance.
A banned event and a more expensive delivery
The only date is prohibited by a binding order
Farah hires Ajay to operate a food stall at a public fair on 10 August. Both sign for that fair and that date alone. Before the fair, an order lawfully prohibits it from going ahead that day. Neither party caused or could prevent the prohibition. The contract has no term governing that event, and no other venue or date meets the promise.
The prohibition came after formation. It prevents the promised performance, and moving the stall to a different fair would be a new arrangement. On those facts the contract would become void under Section 56 when the order made performance unlawful. If Ajay received a ₹12,000 advance and supplied nothing, Section 65 would ordinarily require him to restore that benefit.
An ordinary shipping route closes
Arjun agrees to deliver 200 boxes of tile to Kavita for a fixed price. After signing, a landslide closes the usual road. The contract specifies no route and has no term excusing performance for this event. A longer road remains open, and Arjun can make delivery on time by paying ₹18,000 more for transport.
The landslide is a later event, but it leaves a way to perform the promise as agreed. Delivery has become less profitable. On these facts, Section 56 would be unlikely to discharge the contract. An agreement specifying that only the closed road could be used would call for a different analysis.
What the Supreme Court decided
- Satyabrata Ghose v. Mugneeram Bangur & Co., [1954] SCR 310. The Court rejected frustration when the government temporarily requisitioned land in a development scheme. The interruption and the contract's terms did not show that the bargain's foundation had disappeared.
- Alopi Parshad & Sons Ltd. v. Union of India, [1960] 2 SCR 793. The Court rejected a claim to depart from the agreed rates for ghee supplies after wartime conditions made performance more onerous. An unexpected change in costs alone could not undo the bargain.
- Energy Watchdog v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission, (2017) 14 SCC 80. An increase in the price of Indonesian coal did not qualify as force majeure or frustrate the relevant power purchase agreements. The Court distinguished Section 32 from Section 56 and explained why a more expensive method of performance is insufficient on its own.
What happens to advances under Section 65?
When a contract becomes void, Section 65 requires a person who received an advantage under it to restore that advantage or compensate the person from whom it was received. Work through what each party actually received. An advance for a service never supplied presents a different accounting problem from a contract under which both sides already received benefits.
Start with the promise in the exam problem
- Issue. Identify the later event and the specific performance it prevents or changes.
- Rule. Explain the contractual and statutory routes and the high threshold for Section 56.
- Application. Match the event to the clause if one applies. Examine alternatives, timing and the shared purpose of the bargain. Apply Section 65 to any benefits received if the contract has become void.
- Conclusion. Explain whether the clause supplies relief, the contract becomes void or the original promise remains enforceable.
The English comparison
In England and Wales, the common-law test in Davis Contractors asks whether the change in circumstances would make performance radically different from what the parties agreed to do. The Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943 addresses payments and benefits when it applies. The case brief on Krell v. Henry illustrates a shared purpose disappearing. An Indian problem is governed by the Indian Contract Act.
If an event has interrupted your contract
Keep the signed contract, any notices and records of advances, attempted performance and available alternatives. A local contract lawyer can assess the governing law, notice requirements and deadlines before you suspend performance or make a claim for repayment.
Sources
- Indian Contract Act, 1872, Sections 31, 32, 56 and 65.
- Satyabrata Ghose v. Mugneeram Bangur & Co., [1954] SCR 310.
- Alopi Parshad & Sons Ltd. v. Union of India, [1960] 2 SCR 793.
- Energy Watchdog v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission, (2017) 14 SCC 80, especially paragraphs 32 to 47.
- Davis Contractors Ltd. v. Fareham Urban District Council [1956] AC 696.
- Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, Section 1.

About the author
Priya Pillai is the founder of LegalFly and has taught law for 9 years. She explains case law and legal concepts on the LegalFly YouTube channel.
